Amateur OnlyFans accounts are among the most popular creator subsets, mainly due to their authenticity and resemblance to ‘real’ people. However, with so many accounts to choose from, it can be tricky to narrow down the selection and find one that covers all of the bases.
Not to worry – we’ve done the research and identified the best amateur OnlyFans accounts of 2023. We’ll review these accounts throughout this guide, covering their content and pricing, before highlighting which factors to consider when choosing an amateur account to subscribe to.
The 19 Best Amateur OnlyFans Creators for 2023
Listed below are 19 of the best amateur OnlyFans pages, each offering super-hot content, top-notch responsiveness, and incredible value for money:
- NivyPlays – Best Amateur OnlyFans Creator Who Loves to Sext with Fans
- Chloe Mercy – Incredible OnlyFans Amateur Posting XXX-Rated Sex Videos
- Kiki – Amateur Blonde Bombshell with Eye-Popping Nude Content
- Olivia Ricci – Stunning Italian Blonde on OnlyFans for the First Time
- Susanna Brown – Amateur Brunette Babe with Naughty Media Library
- Peyton Kinsly – Busty Amateur Babe Posting Multiple Times Each Day
- Eva – Super-Hot Amateur Model with Free 31-Day Trial
- Katy Kat – MILF Sex Coach with Free OnlyFans Account
- Maya Ginger – Redheaded Amateur Hottie Who Loves to Sext
- Kara Xaen – Tattooed Amateur Creator with Fetish-Friendly Content
- Putri Cinta – Ebony Goddess Posting Amateur OnlyFans Porn Videos
- Elissa – One of the Best Amateur OnlyFans Accounts for XXX-Rated Content
- SolaZola – Teen Amateur Babe with Top-Notch Responsiveness
- Bri – Sexy Amateur Redhead Posting Regular Cosplay Photos/Videos
- Goddess Jardena – Amateur OnlyFans Page for Dominatrix Content
- Sadie – Amateur Trans Creator Posting Kink-Friendly Media
- Kris Fluffy – Non-Binary Amateur Model with Huge Subscription Discount
- Lacey Claire Rogers – Super-Hot Amateur Girl with Model-Like Physique
- Naughty Cheerleader – Top Amateur OnlyFans Model with Free Subscription
A Closer Look at the Top Amateur OnlyFans Pages to Subscribe to
Now let’s take a closer look at the OnlyFans amateur models listed above, highlighting what they offer and why they’re so highly regarded within the community:
1. NivyPlays – Best Amateur OnlyFans Creator Who Loves to Sext with Fans
Kicking off our discussion of the best amateur OnlyFans creators is NivyPlays. This pink-haired hottie films all of her content herself, adding a sense of realism to her account. Fans can check out what she offers for just $9.99 per month – one of the lowest prices on our list.
Nivy uploads new photos/videos to her wall daily – and these truly need to be seen to be believed. Fans can view solo dildo play videos, stripteases, JOI clips, and so much more. Everything is uncensored in Nivy’s library, and she doesn’t force subscribers to abide by a PPV setup.
This busty babe is also open to custom requests, assuming a healthy tip is attached. Whether fans wish to see her in specific outfits or if they’re looking for a verbal shout-out, Nivy is happy to oblige.
Finally, Nivy also loves participating in all-day sexting sessions with her fans. She’s online pretty much 24/7 and non-judgmental – the perfect combination for chatting via DMs!
|Number of Likes||7,100|
|Number of Posts||190|
|Price||$9.99 per month|
|Number of Photos/Videos||303|
2. Chloe Mercy – Incredible OnlyFans Amateur Posting XXX-Rated Sex Videos
Another of the best amateur OnlyFans accounts is Chloe Mercy. Chloe is a genuine amateur model, producing all her content herself and ensuring fans are treated to an authentic (and revealing) spectacle!
Chloe has one of the best OnlyFans accounts, mainly because of her all-natural body. Chloe’s petite physique is sure to catch the eye – and she’s not afraid to bare all for her fans.
Describing herself as “hornier than most girls my age”, Chloe posts various content types, ensuring fans are never left uninterested. What’s more, as a smaller account, she is able to respond to DMs rapidly, making it easy for fans to build a rapport and engage in long conversations.
This OnlyFans amateur hottie is even offering a 50% discount on her subscription price, meaning fans only need to pay $4 to access her spicy content for 31 days. Due to this and the reasons noted above, Chloe is undoubtedly one of the top amateur OnlyFans creators this year.
|Number of Likes||2,600|
|Number of Posts||56|
|Price||$7.99 per month ($4 for 31 days)|
|Number of Photos/Videos||80|
3. Kiki – Amateur Blonde Bombshell with Eye-Popping Nude Content
Looking for the best Cosplay OnlyFans account in 2023? Kiki has you covered. This super-hot amateur babe is one to check out now. Kiki is a relatively new addition to the OnlyFans scene, yet she has already amassed over 5,200 likes. Access to Kiki’s red-hot media library costs just $12.99 per month – which is well worth it, considering the type of content on offer!
This tattooed sensation isn’t afraid to bare all for her subscribers, with regular nudes and solo play videos being the order of the day. The great thing is that subscribers can also send Kiki messages with something they’d like to see – and if there’s a tip attached, she might make it happen!
Kiki is also an excellent option for those that love sexting, with her replies being some of the fastest on our list. Finally, fans can even buy her sexy outfits from her linked Amazon wish list, which she’ll likely wear in future photos/videos.
|Number of Likes||5,200|
|Number of Posts||430|
|Price||$12.99 per month|
|Number of Photos/Videos||663|
4. Olivia Ricci – Stunning Italian Blonde on OnlyFans for the First Time
Olivia Ricci is a gorgeous Italian blonde amateur model who’s trying out OnlyFans for the first time. We’re pretty sure she’ll find success on the platform given how steamy her early content has been. Olivia is baring it all through full nude photos, public nudity, cosplay, and masturbation videos.
While her account is new, fans shouldn’t let that dissuade them. Olivia is adding content nearly every day and all of it is sure to make fans tremble. Pus, Olivia doesn’t put anything behind a paywall. Subscribers get access to every new photo and video she creates with their subscription.
Subscribing to Olivia’s account only costs $9.99 per month, which is a great deal for the sensuous content this amateur model is putting out there. Olivia is also very responsive to custom requests with a tip. She’ll give fans a shout-out by name, wear a special costume by request, and much more.
|Number of Likes||N/A (brand-new account)|
|Number of Posts||N/A (brand-new account)|
|Price||$9.99 per month|
|Number of Photos/Videos||N/A (brand-new account)|
5. Susanna Brown – Amateur Brunette Babe with Naughty Media Library
Susanna is a curvy brunette amateur with a red-hot media library that subscribers will enjoy. This busty bombshell is relatively new to the OnlyFans scene, yet her content is certainly not to be missed, given its jaw-dropping nature.
Susanna’s media library includes topless photos, lingerie photoshoots, cosplay content, and solo toy play videos. The great thing about Susanna’s page is that she uploads new photos/videos nearly every day and never posts content twice as some other accounts do.
Moreover, Susanna is fetish-friendly, so those with specific fantasies can send her a custom request – which she’ll likely entertain if a tip is attached. All of this (and more) can be obtained for just $7.99 per month, one of the lowest prices on our list!
|Number of Likes||N/A (brand-new account)|
|Number of Posts||N/A (brand-new account)|
|Price||$7.99 per month|
|Number of Photos/Videos||N/A (brand-new account)|
6. Peyton Kinsly – Busty Amateur Babe Posting Multiple Times Each Day
Those seeking the hottest amateur on OnlyFans may wish to check out Peyton Kinsly. This fitness model operates the biggest page on our list, weighing in with over 5.3m likes, yet this doesn’t mean that her content has become inauthentic – quite the opposite!
Peyton posts regular amateur OnlyFans nudes, and given her eye-popping physique, we feel the subscription price of $25 per month is undoubtedly worthwhile. Excitingly, Peyton uploads new content to her wall multiple times daily and occasionally posts fetish–friendly content.
Although her account might not fall into the category of the best cheap OnlyFans pages, Peyton ensures fans are catered to by being open to sexting all day, every day. She even provides exclusive content to fans who opt to re-subscribe each month, meaning her account represents incredible value for money.
|Number of Likes||5.32m|
|Number of Posts||2,285|
|Price||$25 per month ($5 for 31 days)|
|Number of Photos/Videos||3,901|
7. Eva – Super-Hot Amateur Model with Free 31-Day Trial
One of the best amateur OnlyFans girls with a cute/innocent aesthetic is Eva. Eva is a relative newcomer to the OF scene, yet this means her content is genuinely authentic and filmed all by herself. Moreover, she charges just $5 per month for her page – although it can be accessed for free for 31 days!
This amateur teen OnlyFans hottie doesn’t post hardcore content, with most of her photos/videos showcasing her in lingerie, swimsuits, and gym wear. Where Eva stands out is her cheerful and bubbly personality, as she’s more than happy to chat all day with her fans.
Eva also posts new content to her wall daily, ensuring fans are never left bored and uninterested. Finally, fans can even send over custom requests to Eva, which she might accept – if there’s a worthy tip attached!
|Fetish||Girl Next Door|
|Number of Likes||12,000|
|Number of Posts||446|
|Price||$5 per month (FREE for 30 days)|
|Number of Photos/Videos||446|
8. Katy Kat – MILF Sex Coach with Free OnlyFans Account
One of the best MILF OnlyFans accounts featuring an amateur creator is Katy Kat. This sexy seductress is a hypnotist and a sex coach, meaning her content has a true sense of uniqueness. Although she does post regular nudes, Katy also creates content that helps subscribers improve their sex lives and relationships.
This amateur OnlyFans MILF doesn’t charge anything to access her media library since she makes all her income through tips. Her media library contains a little bit of everything, from sex toy reviews to roleplay.
Katy also posts sex tapes with an artistic slant to them, making them unlike anything else on our list. She even has direct links to her YouTube channel, where fans can learn more about her techniques for improving sex and intimacy!
|Number of Likes||244,000|
|Number of Posts||1,344|
|Number of Photos/Videos||3,368|
9. Maya Ginger – Redheaded Amateur Hottie Who Loves to Sext
Maya Ginger has become one of the best OnlyFans Reddit pages to catch the attention recently – and it’s easy to see why! This amateur teen OnlyFans babe describes herself as a “redhead nudist” and posts new content to her wall every day, making her one of the most active creators on our list.
Maya charges just $7.99 per month to access her page, although new subscribers will receive the first month for free. Her content often features collaborative photos/videos with her girlfriend, meaning subscribers get a 2-for-1 deal!
Moreover, Maya is exceptional when it comes to responsiveness and doesn’t utilize any of the best OnlyFans marketing agencies to handle replies. This setup means fans can sext and chat all day since Maya is online pretty much 24/7.
|Number of Likes||25,000|
|Number of Posts||259|
|Price||$7.99 per month (FREE for three days)|
|Number of Photos/Videos||279|
10. Kara Xaen – Tattooed Amateur Creator with Fetish-Friendly Content
Those seeking the best Australian OnlyFans accounts featuring amateur models may wish to check out Kara Xaen. Kara is a busty beauty with several eye-popping tattoos, meaning fans will undoubtedly spend hours admiring her incredible body.
Kara usually charges $15.99 monthly to access her content, yet new fans can subscribe for free for the first 31 days. Her media library contains over 270 HD photos/videos, all without any ads or PPV setup.
Although Kara’s content is less hardcore than some others, this genuine amateur model is more than happy to build relationships with her fans. She also claims to know “everything about fetishes”, making Kara an excellent option for those seeking to fulfil their deepest desires.
|Number of Likes||17,000|
|Number of Posts||271|
|Price||$15.99 per month (FREE for seven days)|
|Number of Photos/Videos||277|
11. Putri Cinta – Ebony Goddess Posting Amateur OnlyFans Porn Videos
Putri Cinta is the best ebony OnlyFans creator on our list, boasting over 150,000 likes at the time of writing. This creator posts regular amateur OnlyFans porn content, including solo toy play, JOI, G/G videos, squirting, and so much more!
Putri adds new content to her wall every day, meaning subscribers never know what they will get with this account! Her page usually costs $12.90 per month, yet Putri is currently running a 75% off deal, meaning fans can get the first month for just $3.23.
Interestingly, Putri even hosts ‘competitions’ on her page, whereby fans can spin a wheel (for a fee) and win super-hot prizes. These prizes include special strip videos, custom videos, roleplay content, or even a one-year subscription for free!
|Number of Likes||150,000|
|Number of Posts||1,002|
|Price||$12.90 per month ($3.23 for 31 days)|
|Number of Photos/Videos||1,744|
12. Elissa – One of the Best Amateur OnlyFans Accounts for XXX-Rated Content
Elissa is an OnlyFans amateur sex goddess with a body that needs to be seen to be believed! As a self-defined “hot model for hot boys”, Elissa isn’t afraid to reveal all and posts new nudes to her wall multiple times daily.
These nudes showcase her incredible busty physique, with absolutely NOTHING left to the imagination. What’s more, Elissa is very fetish-friendly and urges fans to send her custom requests, which she’s usually more than happy to entertain – assuming a tip is attached.
Elissa also occasionally posts G/G action to her feed, ensuring fans of all types are catered to. Those interested in additional content can also purchase her pre-made porn bundles, ranging from $29 to $99.
|Number of Likes||41,000|
|Number of Posts||486|
|Price||$4.99 per month ($3.24 for 31 days)|
|Number of Photos/Videos||545|
13. SolaZola – Teen Amateur Babe with Top-Notch Responsiveness
One of the top amateur OnlyFans pages featuring a teen creator is SolaZola. This Estonian babe has a petite physique and an incredible personality, which can be accessed for $9.98 per month – or $6.99 for the first 31 days.
SolaZola has one of the larger amateur accounts on our list, boasting over 103,000 likes. However, her content remains sexy and authentic, with most pictures/videos showcasing her in lingerie, bikinis, gym wear – or nothing at all!
Aside from amateur OnlyFans nudes, SolaZola also loves to sext all day with her fans. Even though her account is on the larger side, SolaZola still handles all of her own DMs, making it easy for fans to flirt with her and forge a long-lasting connection.
|Number of Likes||103,000|
|Number of Posts||612|
|Price||$9.98 per month ($6.99 for 31 days)|
|Number of Photos/Videos||864|
14. Bri – Sexy Amateur Redhead Posting Regular Cosplay Photos/Videos
Bri is the top OnlyFans amateur for those seeking cosplay-style content. The first thing to note about Bri’s content is that it’s non-nude – so those seeking explicit stuff will need to look elsewhere. However, Bri makes up for this by posting regular photos of her wearing pretty much anything that her fans want her to!
Describing herself as the “sexy nerdy gf of your dreams”, Bri posts new outfit shoots three times per week, with a few lingerie and bikini photos thrown in for good measure. Those seeking extra content can even pay for Bri’s PPV media, which tends to come out monthly.
Bri is also one of the best amateur OnlyFans girls when it comes to value for money, as new subscribers will receive 30% off during their first month. Those who subscribe for an entire year will even receive 40% off – with a few exclusive audio messages also sent to those lucky fans!
|Number of Likes||161,000|
|Number of Posts||308|
|Price||$10 per month ($7 for 31 days)|
|Number of Photos/Videos||757|
15. Goddess Jardena – One of the Best Amateur OnlyFans Pages for Dominatrix Content
Goddess Jardena is the amateur MILF OnlyFans creator on our list that specializes in dominatrix-style content. One look at Jardena’s page will highlight why she has amassed over 23,000 likes in record time, as this sexy seductress posts content that cannot be found elsewhere.
This amateur OnlyFans MILF focuses on a range of femdom-related fetishes, ensuring EVERYONE is catered to. Her media library includes slave tasks, video domination, nude masturbation videos, sissy training, teasing, edging, and so much more.
Jardena is also highly active when it comes to messaging, meaning those interested in humiliation and feminization can easily have their desires fulfilled. Moreover, Jardena only charges $4.99 per month to access her page, making her one of the cheapest creators on our list.
|Number of Likes||23,000|
|Number of Posts||302|
|Price||$4.99 per month|
|Number of Photos/Videos||407|
16. Sadie – Amateur Trans Creator Posting Kink-Friendly Media
We found the hottest amateur OnlyFans creator with a trans background to be Sadie. Sadie is a 21-year-old hottie that posts pretty much everything a subscriber may wish to see, ranging from solo masturbation videos to kink-friendly media.
Sadie charges just $7.99 per month to access her page, which contains over 1,800 high-quality photos/videos for fans to browse through. The great thing is that Sadie adds more content pretty much every day – and is even open to creating custom content for those who ask.
Importantly, subscribers can access ALL of Sadie’s content immediately since she doesn’t use a PPV setup. Finally, Sadie also has her Amazon wish list linked to her profile, meaning fans can buy her items of clothing that she might wear in future videos!
|Number of Likes||24,000|
|Number of Posts||285|
|Price||$7.99 per month|
|Number of Photos/Videos||1,812|
17. Kris Fluffy – Non-Binary Amateur Model with Huge Subscription Discount
Kris Fluffy is one of the top amateur creators when it comes to fetish-friendly content. This non-binary creator has an eye-catching aesthetic and opts for an unshaven look – appealing to those who like the all-natural style!
Kris’s main appeal is the openness to custom requests, as they are more than happy to fulfil ANYTHING that subscribers desire. What’s more, Kris is happy to flirt and sext all day since they’re online pretty much 24/7.
Kris also stands out due to the massive discount on offer, which sees new subscribers receive a whopping 75% off for their first 28 days. Given Kris’s unique aesthetic, this certainly seems like a deal not to be missed!
|Number of Likes||25,000|
|Number of Posts||93|
|Price||$14.99 per month ($3.75 for 31 days)|
|Number of Photos/Videos||93|
18. Lacey Claire Rogers – Super-Hot Amateur Girl with Model-Like Physique
Lacey Claire Rogers operates one of the best new OnlyFans accounts offering amateur content – yet she’s already generating massive momentum within the OF community! This ‘girl next door’ has a cute style, but this doesn’t mean she’s afraid to reveal all to her fans.
For $14.99 per month, fans can access Lacey’s behind-the-scenes content, which usually includes lingerie photos, bikini shoots, and gym pics. However, Lacey doesn’t post any hardcore videos, so fans of XXX-rated content might be best looking elsewhere.
Lacey also uses her OF page to help fans keep track of her lifestyle, meaning there’s a unique blend of SFW and NSFW media. She even has a direct link to her official TikTok account, ideal for those looking to get their daily ‘Lacey fix’.
|Fetish||Girl Next Door|
|Number of Likes||20,000|
|Number of Posts||589|
|Price||$14.99 per month|
|Number of Photos/Videos||1,110|
19. Naughty Cheerleader – Top Amateur OnlyFans Model with Free Subscription
The final entry on our list of the best amateur OnlyFans pages is Naughty Cheerleader. Those seeking to find the best free OnlyFans accounts should look no further since Naughty Cheerleader doesn’t charge a cent to access her content!
Naughty Cheerleader’s main appeal is the fully-fledged girlfriend experience that she offers. This feature means fans can chat with her 24/7, with Naughty Cheerleader truly engaged in what everyone says.
She’s also among the best amateur OnlyFans creators due to her spicy media library, which contains over 2,500 eye-popping photos/videos. Naughty Cheerleader even provides live streams every week, ensuring a level of interactivity that is rarely seen with OF amateurs!
|Number of Likes||42,000|
|Number of Posts||1,908|
|Number of Photos/Videos||2,520|
How to Find the Top Amateur OnlyFans Girls
Much like deciding which of the best cam sites to sign up to, identifying the top amateur creators involves in-depth research and comparison. To streamline this research process, detailed below are six factors to bear in mind, all of which tend to signal a high-quality account:
Frequency of Uploads
The best amateur OnlyFans accounts all ensure they upload regularly – either daily or multiple times per week. This approach is crucial, as it means that the account never becomes dull and uninspiring. Choosing a creator that posts a blend of photos and videos is also essential, as these help create an appealing level of variety.
Authenticity & Speed of Replies
Many amateur OnlyFans pages will also focus heavily on responsiveness. This aspect refers to how quick and authentic replies are, both of which are key determinants of a long-lasting relationship.
Most amateurs will ensure they reply to every DM, although the larger pages may take a little longer to message back. That’s why subscribers who leave a tip tend to receive priority replies since it’s in the creator’s best interests to focus on them first.
Open to Custom Requests
The top amateur OF creators will also be open to custom requests, ensuring they can create a personalized experience for all subscribers. Whether to facilitate a request or not rests solely with the creator – and fans usually need to provide a worthwhile tip if they’re to be accepted.
Some popular custom requests include verbal shoutouts in a video, wearing a specific item of clothing, posing in a certain way, or even writing the subscriber’s name on their chest.
Free vs Paid Accounts
Everything from the best Japanese OnlyFans pages to the top Amateur OnlyFans accounts are split into two categories – free accounts and paid accounts. A common misconception is that free accounts tend to have lower-quality content, but this isn’t the case!
Often, these free accounts act as a sort of ‘trial’ for the paid version. Thus, fans can check out what’s on offer through the free account, and if they like what they see, they can get involved with the full paid experience.
Type of Photos/Videos Offered
Many creators offer amateur OnlyFans porn content, yet some veer away from the hardcore stuff. This all depends on the creator, so reading the creator’s bio and gaining insight into what they offer is essential. Fortunately, many creators provide ALL types of content, ensuring every subscriber is catered to.
Links to Social Media Channels
Finally, some creators will also post direct links to their social media channels in their OF bio. Although this may seem like a minor feature, it adds a sense of authenticity to the page, as fans can check out what they’re up to and receive additional content.
Some creators may even post links to third-party sites that offer even more features. This tends to include the scope to buy worn items of clothing, which will be sent directly to the subscriber’s residence.
Conclusion — Who is the Best Hottest OnlyFans Creator to Follow?
To conclude, this guide has taken an in-depth look at the best amateur OnlyFans accounts of 2023, covering what they offer, how much they cost, and the elements that help them stand out.
Our top pick right now when it comes to OnlyFans amateur creators is NivyPlays. This petite sensation has an incredible body and a personality to match – with fans able to get involved for just $9.99 per month.
Apart from her stunning good looks, Nivy excels when it comes to responsiveness. All replies come directly from her, making it quick and easy to establish a genuine (and long-lasting) connection!