USA
  • Crypto Guides
    • Crypto Guides
    • Best Cryptos
      • Best Cryptos
      • Best Meme Coins
      • Best Web 3.0 Coins
      • Best Beginner Cryptos
      • Best Crypto ETFs
      • Best BSC Tokens
      • Best Crypto Tips
      • Best Crypto Tools
      • Best Cryptos to Trade
      • Best Cryptos Under $1
      • Best Crypto VC Firms
      • Best Crypto Winter Tokens
      • Best Deflationary Cryptos
      • Best Emerging Cryptos
      • Best ERC20 Tokens
      • Best Future Cryptocurrency
      • Best Move to Earn Crypto
      • Best PoS Coins
      • Best PoW Coins
      • Best Utility Tokens
      • Best Video Game Crypto
      • Coins to Buy on the Dip
      • Best Crypto to Buy During the Bear Market
      • Coins With Most Upside
      • Cryptos That Could Make You Rich
      • Eco Friendly Cryptos
      • Energy Efficient Cryptos
      • Fastest Growing Crypto
      • Greenest Cryptocurrencies
      • Hottest Cryptos Right Now
      • Long Term Investments
      • Low Market Cap Cryptos
      • Low Supply Cryptos
      • Most Profitable Cryptos
      • Most Promising Cryptos
      • Most Searched Cryptos
      • Most Undervalued Cryptos
      • Most Volatile Cryptos
      • Next Crypto to Explode
      • Penny Cryptocurrencies
      • Sustainable Cryptos
      • Top Crypto Gainers
      • Top Trending Cryptos
      • Trending DEXTools Cryptos
    • Best Altcoins
      • Best Altcoins
      • Buy Battle Infinity
      • Buy Bitcoin Cash
      • Buy Binance Coin
      • Buy Celo
      • Buy Calvaria
      • Buy Cardano
      • Buy Cartesi
      • Buy C+Charge Token
      • Buy Chiliz
      • Buy Copium Protocol
      • Buy Cronos
      • Buy Crypto Snack
      • Buy Dash
      • Buy Dash 2 Trade
      • Buy EOS
      • Buy ENS
      • Buy Ethereum
      • Is Ethereum a Good Investment?
      • Is it too Late to Buy Ethereum?
      • Buy Ethereum Classic
      • Buy Fight Out Token
      • Buy FTX Token
      • Buy HBAR
      • Buy IMPT
      • Buy IOST
      • Buy IOTA
      • Buy Litecoin
      • Buy Livepeer
      • Buy Loopring
      • Buy Lucky Block
      • Buy LUNA 2.0
      • Buy LUNC
      • Buy MEMAG
      • Buy Neo
      • Buy Pitbull Coin
      • Buy Polkadot
      • Buy RadioCaca
      • Buy Solana
      • Buy Spark
      • Buy VeChain
      • Buy XRP
      • Buy ZCash
    • New Cryptos
      • New Cryptos
      • Best Crypto ICOs
      • Best Crypto IDOs
      • Best Crypto IEOs
      • Best Crypto STOs
      • Best Crypto Crowdsales
      • Best Crypto Presales
      • Best Crypto Private Sales
      • Buying Coins Pre Launch
      • New Binance Listings
      • New Coinbase Listings
    • Buy Crypto
      • Buy Crypto
      • Buy Bitcoin
      • Buy BTC with Apple Pay
      • Buy BTC with Credit Card
      • Buy BTC with Bank Wire
      • Buy BTC with eToro
      • Buy BTC with Paypal
      • Buy BTC with Prepaid Card
      • How to Invest in Bitcoin
      • How Much Bitcoin Should I Buy?
      • How to Invest in Crypto
      • Is Cryptocurrency a Good Investment
      • How Much Should You Invest in Crypto?
    • Crypto Games
      • Crypto Games
      • Best Blockchain Games
      • Best GameFi Cryptos
      • Best Gaming Crypto Coins
      • Best Play to Earn Games
      • Best Video Game Cryptos
    • Best Crypto Exchanges
      • Best Crypto Exchanges
      • Best Crypto Auto Trading Platforms
      • Best Altcoin Exchange
      • Best Decentralized Exchanges
      • Best Metaverse Platforms
      • Best Crypto Apps
      • Best DeFi Exchange
      • Best P2P Exchange
      • Binance Referral Bonus
      • Binance vs Coinbase
      • Binance Review
      • Best Binance Alternatives
      • Best Coinbase Alternatives
      • Bitstamp Review
      • Bitstamp Sign Up Bonus
      • Coinbase Review
      • Coinbase Sign Up Bonus
      • Crypto.com Review
      • Crypto.com Sign Up Bonus
      • Crypto.com Visa Card
      • Crypto Credit Cards
      • Crypto Tax Software
      • ICONOMI Review
      • Margin Trading Exchanges
      • Social Trading Platforms
    • Crypto Groups & Socials
      • Crypto Groups & Socials
      • Best Crypto Alert Sites
      • Best Crypto Reddit
      • Best Crypto Signals
      • Crypto Discord Groups
      • Crypto Tiktok Trends
      • Crypto Youtube Channels
      • Twitter Crypto Trends
    • Crypto Wallets
      • Crypto Wallets
      • Best Cardano Wallets
      • Best Ethereum Wallets
      • Best XRP Wallets
      • Crypto Bank Accounts
      • How to Spend Bitcoin
      • How to Spend Ethereum
    • Bitcoin Price Prediction
      • Bitcoin Price Prediction
      • ApeCoin Price Prediction
      • Axie Infinity Prediction
      • Battle Infinity Prediction
      • Celsius Price Prediction
      • Calvaria Price Prediction
      • Cardano Price Prediction
      • C+Charge Price Prediction
      • Chia Coin Price Prediction
      • Dash 2 Trade Price Prediction
      • DeFi Coin Price Prediction
      • DogeBonk Price Prediction
      • Dogecoin Price Prediction
      • Dogelon Mars Prediction
      • Ethereum Price Prediction
      • Fight Out Price Prediction
      • Floki Inu Price Prediction
      • Gala Price Prediction
      • Hedera Hashgraph Price Prediction
      • Hoge Coin Price Prediction
      • LBLOCK V1 Prediction
      • LBLOCK V2 Prediction
      • LUNA Price Prediction
      • MetaBlaze Price Prediction
      • MEMAG Price Prediction
      • Pi Coin Price Prediction
      • Polygon Price Prediction
      • SafeMoon Price Prediction
      • Shiba Inu Price Prediction
      • Solana Price Prediction
      • Tamadoge Price Prediction
      • Tornado Cash Prediction
      • XRP Price Prediction
    • Earn Free Crypto
      • Earn Free Crypto
      • Best Crypto Airdrops
      • Best Crypto Faucets
      • Best Crypto Giveaways
      • Earn Free Bitcoin
      • Make Money With Crypto
    • Earn Interest on Crypto
      • Earn Interest on Crypto
      • Aqru Review
      • Best Staking Coins
      • Crypto Interest Accounts
      • Crypto Lending Platforms
      • Crypto Loan Sites
      • Crypto Savings Accounts
      • Crypto Staking
      • Best Crypto Portfolio Tracker Tools
      • Earn Interest on Bitcoin
      • Earn interest on Ethereum
      • Earn Interest on Stables
      • What is APY in Crypto?
      • Yield Farming Platforms
      • Yield Farming vs Staking
    • DeFi Crypto Guides
      • DeFi Crypto Guides
      • Best DeFi Coins
      • Best DeFi Apps
      • Best DeFi Interest Rates
      • Best DeFi Wallets
      • Best DEX Coins
      • DAO Crypto Projects
      • DeFi Lending Platforms
      • DeFi Staking Platforms
      • DeFi Swap Exchange
      • DeFi Yield Farming
      • How to Invest in DeFi
    • Worldwide Crypto Guides
      • Worldwide Crypto Guides
      • Best Africa Crypto Projects
      • Best Asia Crypto Projects
      • Best China Crypto Projects
      • Best Dubai Crypto Projects
      • Buy Bitcoin AU
      • Buy Bitcoin CA
      • Buy Bitcoin DE
      • Buy Bitcoin SA
      • Buy Dogecoin SA
      • Buy Bitcoin SG
      • Buy Bitcoin UAE
      • Buy Bitcoin UK
      • Crypto Exchanges AU
      • Crypto Exchanges CA
      • Crypto Exchanges DE
      • Crypto Exchanges SA
      • Crypto Exchanges SG
      • Crypto Exchanges UAE
      • Crypto Exchanges UK
    • Bitcoin Mining Sites
      • Bitcoin Mining Sites
      • Best Coins to Mine
      • Ethereum Mining
      • Litecoin Mining
      • Monero Mining
    • Development & Marketing
      • Development & Marketing
      • Financial PR Agencies
      • ICO Marketing
      • NFT Marketing
      • Web3 Marketing
      • Blockchain Development Agencies
      • 10 Best Blockchain App Development Agencies
      • Web3 Development Agencies
  • NFTs
    • NFTs
    • How To Buy NFTs
      • How To Buy NFTs
      • Best NFT Apps
      • Best NFT Games
      • Best NFT Giveaways
      • Best NFT Lawyers
      • Best NFT Lottery Sites
      • Best NFT Presales
      • Best NFT Staking Projects
      • Best NFT Wallets
      • Best Utility NFT Projects
      • Buy NFTs on Binance
      • How to Flip NFTs
      • Make Money With NFTs
      • NFT Signals
    • Best Metaverse Coins
      • Best Metaverse Coins
      • Buy ApeCoin
      • Buy Axie Infinity
      • Buy Decentraland
      • Buy DeFi Kingdoms
      • Buy Enjin
      • Buy Gala
      • Buy GMT
      • Buy Immutable X
      • Buy The Sandbox
    • NFT News
      • NFT News
      • Celebrity Backed NFTs
      • Celebrity NFT Owners
      • Cheapest NFT Projects
      • Coolest NFT Projects
      • Most Expensive NFTs
      • New NFT Projects
      • Upcoming NFT Drops
      • NFT Calendar
      • NFT Horse Racing Projects
      • NFT Trading Card Games
      • Sport NFT Drops
    • Invest in the Metaverse
      • Invest in the Metaverse
      • Best Metaverse Apps
      • Best Metaverse Games
      • How to Invest in NFTs
      • Metaverse Projects
      • Metaverse Real Estate
      • Real Estate Investment Club Review
      • Identity 20XY Review
      • NFT Land Projects
    • Best NFTs To Buy
      • Best NFTs To Buy
      • Azuki NFTs
      • CryptoPunks NFTs
      • Lucky Block NFTs
      • PolygonPunks NFTs
      • Prime Ape Planet NFTs
      • VeeFriends NFTs
      • World of Women NFTs
    • NFT Marketplaces
      • NFT Marketplaces
      • Binance
      • Crypto.com
      • DraftKings
      • Looksrare
      • Magic Eden
      • NFT Launchpad
      • NFT Music Platforms
      • OpenSea
      • Rarible
  • Stocks
    • Stocks
    • Types of Stocks
      • Types of Stocks
      • Best Biotech Stocks
      • Best Bitcoin ETFs
      • Best Blockchain Stocks
      • Best Cannabis Stocks
      • Best Carbon Credit Stocks
      • Best Cheap Stocks
      • Best Climate Change Stocks
      • Best Cybersecurity Stocks
      • Best DeFi Stocks
      • Best Dividend Stocks
      • Best Ethical Stocks
      • Best Energy Stocks
      • Best ESG Investing Stocks
      • Best Renewable Energy Stocks
      • Best Meme Stocks
      • Best Metaverse Stocks
      • Best New Stocks
      • Best NFT Stocks
      • Best Oil Stocks
      • Best Penny Stocks
      • Best Reddit Stocks
      • Best Small-Cap Stocks
      • Best Tech Stocks
      • Best 5G Stocks
      • Best Upcoming IPOs
      • Best Uranium Stocks
      • Most Undervalued Stocks
    • Company Stocks
      • Company Stocks
      • Buy Adobe Stock
      • Buy Alibaba Stock
      • Buy Alphabet Stock
      • Buy Amazon Stock
      • Buy Apple Stock
      • Buy AMC Stock
      • Buy AT&T Stock
      • Buy Disney Stock
      • Buy DocuSign Stock
      • Buy DWAC Stock
      • Buy eBay Stock
      • Buy Etsy Stock
      • Buy Ford Stock
      • Buy Gamestop Stock
      • Buy Hertz Stock
      • Buy iRobot Stock
      • Buy Lockheed Martin Stock
      • Buy Matterport Stock
      • Buy Monday.com Stock
      • Buy Meta Stock
      • Buy Medifast Stock
      • Buy Microsoft Stock
      • Buy Netflix Stock
      • Buy Nike Stock
      • Buy Nikola Stock
      • Buy NRG Stock
      • Buy Rivian Stock
      • Buy Roblox Stock
      • Buy Peloton Stock
      • Buy Pfizer Stock
      • Buy Porsche Stock
      • Buy SAVA Stock
      • Buy Spotify Stock
      • Buy Tesla Stock
      • Buy Samsung Stock
      • Buy Uber Stock
      • Buy Upstart Stock
      • Buy XELA Stock
      • Buy Zoom Stock
    • Buy Stocks
      • Buy Stocks
      • Buy Shares UK
      • Best Shares to Buy UK
      • How to Buy Alphabet Shares UK
      • How to Buy Apple Shares UK
      • How to Buy Amazon Shares UK
      • Buy Shares in Australia
      • Buy Stocks in Germany
      • Buy Stocks in India
      • Buy Stocks in Netherlands
      • Buy Stocks in Saudi Arabia
      • Buy Stocks in Singapore
      • Buy Shares in South Africa
      • Buy Stocks in Vietnam
      • Buy 5G Stocks
      • Buy Cannabis Stocks
      • Buy Coinbase Stocks
      • Buy Dividend Stocks
      • Buy Nio Stock
      • Buy Oil Stocks
      • Buy Stocks on eToro
      • Buy Stocks via Credit Card
      • Buy Stocks with PayPal
      • Invest in Stocks
      • Recession-Proof Stocks
      • Invest in NFT Stocks
  • Trading
    • Trading
    • Best Trading Platforms
      • Best Trading Platforms
      • Best Trading Platforms Saudi Arabia
      • Best CFD Brokers
      • Best CFD Brokers AU
      • Best CFD Brokers UK
      • Best Stock Trading App UK
      • Best Futures Brokers
      • Best Investment Apps
      • Best WhatsApp Trading Signals
      • Copy Trading Platforms
      • Crypto Price Trackers
      • Demo Accounts for Stocks
      • Day Trading Platforms UK
      • eToro Review
      • eToro Review UK
      • Plus500 Review AU
      • Plus500 Review UK
      • How to Day Trade Stocks
      • How to Trade Commodities
      • How to Trade Crypto
      • Is Forex Trading Profitable?
      • Stocks vs Forex Trading
      • What is Carbon Credit Trading?
      • What is ETF Trading?
      • What is Forex Trading?
      • Is Forex Legit?
      • What is Fibonacci in Forex?
      • What is a Lot in Forex?
      • What is a Pip in Forex?
      • What is Quant Trading?
      • What is Trend Trading?
      • How to Trade ETFs
      • How to Trade Gold
      • How to Trade NFTs
      • How to Trade Oil
      • Islamic Brokers
      • Gold Trading Brokers
      • Low Margin Rate Brokers
      • Bitcoineer Review
      • Paper Trading Platforms
      • Pepperstone Review
      • Risk Management in Forex
      • XTB Review
    • Best Forex Brokers
      • Best Forex Brokers
      • ASIC Regulated Brokers
      • Automated Forex Trading
      • Best Forex Cent Accounts
      • Best Forex Managed Accounts
      • Best Forex Trading Apps
      • Best Forex Strategies
      • Best Forex VPS
      • Best Free VPS Brokers
      • Best Forex Brokers AU
      • Best Forex Brokers CA
      • Best Forex Brokers IN
      • Best Forex Brokers UAE
      • Best Forex Brokers UK
      • Best Neteller Forex Brokers
      • Best Payoneer FX Brokers
      • Best Skrill Forex Brokers
      • Best WU Forex Brokers
      • Best NDD Forex Brokers
      • Best Forex Bonuses
      • Best Forex Signals
      • Best Micro Forex Accounts
      • Best MT4 Brokers
      • Best MT5 Brokers
      • Best ECN Brokers
      • Best STP Brokers
      • Best Pairs to Trade in Forex
      • Evest Review
      • GO Markets Australia Review
      • GO Markets Review UK
      • Most Volatile Forex Pairs
      • Best Scalping Brokers
      • Bitcoin Forex Brokers
      • CySEC Forex Brokers
      • Forex Copy Trading
      • High Leverage Brokers
      • Low Spread Forex Brokers
      • PAMM Account Brokers
      • Spread Betting Brokers UK
      • Swap Free Account Brokers
    • Trading Robots
      • Trading Robots
      • Algorithmic Trading
      • Bitcode AI Review
      • BitiCodes Review
      • Bitindex Prime Review
      • BitIQ Review
      • BitTrader Review
      • Bitsoft360 Review
      • BitVestment Review
      • Crypto Bank Review
      • Crypto Boom Review
      • Crypto Engine Review
      • Finixio AI Review
      • Immediate Connect Review
      • Immediate Edge Review
      • Meta Profit Review
      • Metaverse Profit Review
      • NFT Profit Review
      • Oil Profit Review
      • Prime Advantage Review
      • Quantum AI Review
      • Quantum Code Review
      • Teslacoin Review
      • Today Profit Review
      • xBitcoin AI Review
      • xBitcoin App Review
      • xBitcoin Club Review
      • 7Tesler Review
    • Bitcoin Robots
      • Bitcoin Robots
      • Best Crypto Trading Bots
      • Automated Trading
      • BitAlpha AI Review
      • Bitcoin 360 Ai Review
      • Bitcoin Blueprint Review
      • Bitcoin Circuit Review
      • Bitcoin Code Review
      • Bitcoin Digital Review
      • Bitcoin Freedom Review
      • Bitcoin Motion Review
      • Bitcoin Prime Review
      • Bitcoin Profit Review
      • Bitcoin Revolution Review
      • Bitcoin Rocket Review
      • Bitcoin Smarter Review
      • Bitcoin Thunderbolt Review
      • Bitcoin Trader Review
      • Bitcoin Up Review
      • Bitcoin XOX Review
      • BitcoinX Review
      • Bitprime Gold Review
      • BitProfit Review
      • Bit Index AI Review
      • British Bitcoin Profit
  • Investing
    • Investing
    • What to Invest in Right Now
    • Best Sectors to Invest in
    • How to Invest $1,000
    • How to Invest $2,000
    • How to Invest $5,000
    • How to Invest $10k
    • How to Invest $20k
    • How to Invest $25k
    • How to Invest $40k
    • How to Invest $50k
    • Best Way to Invest $100k
    • Best Way to Invest $250k
    • Best Way to Invest $500k
    • Best Investments UK
      • Best Investments UK
      • How to Invest in the UK According to Reddit
      • Best Stocks and Shares ISAs UK
      • Best Mutual Funds UK
      • Best Index Funds UK
      • Best Bonds to Buy in the UK
      • Best Way to Invest £5k UK
      • Best Way to Invest £10k UK
      • Best Way to Invest £20k UK
      • Best Way to Invest £25k UK
      • Best Way to Invest £50k UK
      • Best Way to Invest £75k UK
      • Best Way to Invest £100k UK
      • Best Way to Invest £500k UK
      • Best Short Term Investments UK
    • How to Invest According to Reddit
    • How to Invest in Blockchain
    • How to Invest in Bonds
    • How to Buy Carbon Credits
    • How to Invest in Carbon Credits
    • Best Carbon Offset Programs
    • Best Carbon Credits ETFs
    • What is Sustainable Investing?
    • Best Sustainable Investing Funds
    • Best Sustainable Investments UK
    • What is Green Energy Investing?
    • How to Invest in Clean Energy
    • Best Green Investment Funds
    • How to Buy Carbon Credits Australia
    • How to Buy Carbon Credits UK
    • How to Invest in Commodities
    • How to Invest in ETFs
    • How to Invest in Index Funds
    • Best Crypto Index Funds
    • How to Invest in Mutual Funds
    • Best Crypto Mutual Funds
    • How to Invest in Pre-IPOs
    • How to Invest in Startups
    • How to Invest in REITs
    • How to Invest in Web3
    • How to Invest During Inflation
    • What is Socially Responsible Investing?
    • What is ESG Investing?
    • Best ESG Investing Funds
    • What is Dividend Investing?
    • What is Impact Investing?
    • What is Value Investing?
  • Software & Social
    • Software & Social
    • VPN
      • VPN
      • Best VPN Services
      • Best Cheap VPN
      • Fastest VPN Services
      • Best Netflix VPN
      • Best VPN For iPhone
      • Best VPN for Android
      • Best VPN App
      • Best VPN for Gaming
      • Best VPN UK
      • Best Linux VPN
      • Best VPN for Firestick UK
      • How to Watch Love Island UK From Abroad
      • ExpressVPN Review 2022 | Is ExpressVPN the Best VPN?
      • Best VPN Canada
      • Best VPN for Android UK
      • The Best VPNs For The USA In 2022 | Unblock Content With a US VPN
      • Best VPN UAE
      • Best VPN India
      • Best VPN Malaysia
      • Best VPN Singapore
      • Best VPN Reddit
      • Best Betfair VPN
    • Spy Software
      • Spy Software
      • Best Phone Spy Apps
      • Best Spy App for Android
      • Best Spy App for iPhone
      • Best Facebook Spy Apps
      • Best WhatsApp Spy Apps
      • Best Tinder Spy Apps
      • Best Instagram Spy Apps
      • Best Keylogger Apps
      • Best Call Logger Apps
      • Best Web Browsing History Trackers
      • How To Spy on Cricket Cell Phones
      • Best Keyloggers for Windows
      • Best No Jailbreak iPhone Spy Apps
      • Best Android Call Loggers
      • Best Secret Screen Recorder Apps
    • Hosting
      • Hosting
      • Best WordPress Hosting
      • Cheap WordPress Hosting
      • Enterprise Hosting
      • Small Business Hosting
      • UK WordPress Hosting
      • WordPress VPS Hosting
      • Best WordPress Managed Hosting
    • Agencies
      • Agencies
      • Best Content Marketing Agencies
      • Mobile App Development
      • Social Media Marketing
      • Influencer Marketing
      • Best Instagram Marketing Agencies
      • Best Google Ads Agencies
      • Email Marketing Agencies
      • Best Link Building Agencies
      • Best PR Agencies
      • Best Recruitment Agencies
      • Best SEO Agencies
      • Best Snapchat Advertising Agencies
      • Best Tiktok Influencer Agencies
      • Best TikTok Marketing Agencies
      • Best Twitter Ads Agencies
      • Best Pinterest Ad Agencies
      • Best Bing Ad Agencies
      • Best Facebook Ad Agencies
      • Best Recruitment Agencies
      • Best Branding Agencies
      • Best SEO Agencies India
      • Best Programmatic Ads Agencies
      • Best Creative Agencies
      • Best Mobile App Development Companies India
      • Best Translation Agencies
      • Best Display Ads Agencies
      • Best Talent Agencies
      • Best Web Development Companies India
      • Best Magento Agencies
      • Best Sports Management Companies for 2022
      • Best CRO Agencies
      • Best Amazon Advertising Agencies
    • Other Software
      • Other Software
      • Best Dental Software UK
      • The Best App Builder in 2022 | Top 15 No-Code App Builders Reviewed
      • Best Legal Software UK
      • Job Mgmt Software UK
      • Best HR Software UK
      • Best Payroll Software UK
      • Inventory Management
    • Marketing
      • Marketing
      • SEO Marketplaces
      • Email Marketing
    • Workflow
      • Workflow
      • PM Software
      • PM Software Small Teams
      • Marketing PM Software
      • Free PM Software
      • Best Scheduling Software
      • Best Scheduling Apps
      • Task Management Tools
      • Best PM Apps
      • Best Agile Tools
      • The Best Background Check Software | Top 12 Reviewed for 2022
      • The 92 Best Small Business Ideas for 2022 | Ranked by Category
    • Best Antivirus Software
      • Best Antivirus Software
      • Best Antivirus Software CA
      • Best Antivirus Software IN
      • Best Antivirus Software SG
      • Best Antivirus Software UK
      • How to Remove Spyware | Best Spy App Removal Tools in 2022
    • Password Managers
      • Password Managers
      • Best Pw Manager Australia
      • Best Pw Manager Canada
      • Best Pw Manager UK
    • Accounting Software
      • Accounting Software
      • Free Accounting Software
      • Mac Accounting Software
    • Best Website Builders
      • Best Website Builders
      • Best App Builder
      • Best Ecommerce Platform
      • Best Landing Page Builder
    • Affiliate Marketing
      • Affiliate Marketing
      • Best Affiliate Programs
      • Crypto Affiliate Programs
      • Financial Affiliate Programs
      • Financial Affiliate Programs
    • VoIP
      • VoIP
      • Best VoIP Services
      • Virtual Landline UK
      • Virtual Phone For Business
      • Virtual Phone Number US
      • VoIP Home Phone CA
      • Best Office Phone Systems
    • Dating
      • Dating
      • Best Dating Apps
      • Best Dating Apps AU
      • Best Dating Apps CA
      • Best Dating Apps UK
    • Adult
      • Adult
      • Best Adult Cam Sites
    • OnlyFans
      • OnlyFans
      • Best OnlyFans Accounts
      • Best OnlyFans Reddit Pages
      • Best Latina OnlyFans Accounts
      • Best Asian OnlyFans Accounts
    • CRM
      • CRM
      • Best CRM Software
      • Free CRM Software
      • Best Client Management Software
      • Best Sales CRM
      • CRM Software For Small Business
    • SEO Software
      • SEO Software
      • Ahrefs Review
      • E-mail Marketing
      • Semrush Review
    • Social Media
      • Social Media
      • Get More Views on Instagram
      • How To Create a Blog
    • POS
      • POS
      • The Best POS Systems in 2022 | Simplify Payments With POS Tools
      • Best POS Systems for Small Businesses
      • Best iPad POS Systems
      • Best Retail POS Systems
      • Best POS Systems for Restuarants
      • Best POS Systems Canada : Top 10 for 2022
      • Bes POS Systems UK
  • Gambling
    • Gambling
    • Bitcoin Casinos
      • Bitcoin Casinos
      • Best Bitcoin Casino Free Spins
      • Best Provably Fair Bitcoin Casinos
      • Best Bitcoin Casinos with Instant Withdrawals
      • 10 Best Bitcoin Esports Betting Sites
      • Best Altcoin Casinos
      • Best Bitcoin Casinos Australia
      • Best Crypto Gambling Sites Australia
      • Best Bitcoin Pokies Sites Australia
      • Best Bitcoin Casinos Brazil
      • Best Bitcoin Casinos Canada
      • Best Bitcoin Casinos Indonesia
      • Best Bitcoin Casinos Korea
      • Best Bitcoin Casinos Malaysia
      • Best Bitcoin Casinos New Zealand
      • Best Bitcoin Casinos Philippines
      • Best Bitcoin Casinos South Africa
      • Best Bitcoin Casinos Thailand
      • Best Bitcoin Casinos UK
      • Best Crypto Casinos Vietnam
      • Best Bitcoin Gambling Sites
      • Best Bitcoin Cash Casinos
      • 10 Best Crash Gambling Sites
      • Best Decentralized Gambling Sites
      • Best Ethereum Gambling Sites
      • Best Crypto Lotteries
      • Best Plinko Gambling Sites
      • Best Solana Gambling sites
      • Bitcoin Blackjack Sites
      • Bitcoin Poker Sites
      • Bitcoin Roulette Sites
      • Bitcoin Slots Sites
      • Ethereum Casinos
      • Best Metamask Casino Sites
      • Best Mines Gambling Sites
      • Best NFT Gambling Sites
      • 8 Best Neo Casinos
      • 7 Best Tron Casinos
      • Crypto Casino
      • BlueChip Review
      • BC.Game Review
      • Bitstarz Alternatives
      • Cloudbet Review
      • Heatz Review
      • SX Bet Review
      • Vave Casino Review
      • Wild.io Casino Review
    • Best Crypto Betting Sites
      • Best Crypto Betting Sites
      • Super Bowl Bitcoin Betting Sites
    • Best Online Sportsbooks
      • Best Online Sportsbooks
      • Best Offshore Sportsbooks
      • Best Football Betting Sites
      • Best Online Sportsbook For Payouts
      • New Betting Sites & Sportsbooks
      • Super Bowl Betting Sites
      • How to Bet on the Super Bowl
      • Sports Betting Promo Codes
      • Best Reddit Sportsbooks
    • Best Sports Betting Apps
      • Best Sports Betting Apps
      • NFL Betting Apps
      • Boxing Betting Apps
      • Horse Racing Betting Apps
      • Soccer Betting Apps
      • Golf Betting Apps
      • Cricket Betting Apps
      • UFC Betting Apps
    • Real Money Online Casino
      • Real Money Online Casino
      • Best Real Money Casino Apps
      • Offshore Casinos
      • Live Dealer Online Casino
      • Best New Casinos USA
      • Best Mobile Casinos
      • Online Casino Bonus Promotions
      • Best Payout Online Casinos
      • Fast Payout Online Casino Sites
      • Best Craps Casinos
      • Best Online Blackjack Casino
      • How to Play Baccarat
      • Best Online Roulette Casinos
      • Best American Roulette Casinos
      • Best European Roulette Casinos
      • How to Play Roulette
      • Blackjack Live Dealer Casinos
      • Best Real Money Blackjack Apps
      • Credit Card Casinos
      • Vanilla Visa Casinos
      • Cash App Casinos
      • $10 Deposit Casinos
      • Best No ID Verification Casinos
      • Play’n GO Casino Sites
      • Pragmatic Casino Sites
      • Curaçao Online Casinos
      • Best Casino Streamers
    • State Sports Betting Guides
      • State Sports Betting Guides
      • Alabama Sports Betting
      • Alaska Sports Betting
      • California Sports Betting
      • Florida Sports Betting
      • Kansas Sports Betting
      • Michigan Sports Betting
      • Minnesota Sports Betting
      • Missouri Sports Betting
      • Montana Sports Betting
      • Nebraska Sports Betting
      • Nevada Sports Betting
      • New York Sports Betting
      • North Carolina Sports Betting
      • Ohio Sports Betting
      • Texas Sports Betting
      • Wisconsin Sports Betting
      • Massachusetts Sports Betting
    • State Betting App Guides
      • State Betting App Guides
      • Delaware Sports Betting Apps
      • Florida Sports Betting Apps
      • Georgia Sports Betting Apps
      • Kentucky Sports Betting Apps
      • Louisiana Sports Betting Apps
      • Maine Sports Betting Apps
      • Maryland Sports Betting Apps
      • Michigan Sports Betting Apps
      • Minnesota Sports Betting Apps
      • Mississippi Sports Betting Apps
      • Missouri Sports Betting Apps
      • Nebraska Sports Betting Apps
      • New Jersey Sports Betting Apps
      • New Mexico Sports Betting Apps
      • New York Sports Betting Apps
      • North Carolina Sports Betting Apps
      • North Dakota Sports Betting Apps
      • Oklahoma Sports Betting Apps
      • Oregon Sports Betting Apps
      • Pennsylvania Sports Betting Apps
      • Rhode Island Sports Betting Apps
      • South Carolina Sports Betting Apps
      • South Dakota Sports Betting Apps
      • Texas Sports Betting Apps
      • Utah Sports Betting Apps
      • Vermont Sports Betting Apps
      • West Virginia Sports Betting Apps
    • State Casino Guides
      • State Casino Guides
      • California Casino Apps
      • Colorado Casino Apps
      • Florida Online Casinos
      • Florida Casino Apps
      • Indiana Online Casinos
      • Louisiana Casino Apps
      • Maryland Online Casinos
      • Maryland Online Casino Apps
      • Michigan Online Casinos
      • Missouri Online Casinos
      • New York Online Casinos
      • New York Casino Apps
      • North Carolina Casino Apps
      • Ohio Online Casinos
      • Oklahoma Casino Apps
      • South Dakota Casino Apps
      • Texas Casino Apps
    • State Gambling Guides
      • State Gambling Guides
      • Florida Online Gambling
      • Ohio Online Gambling
    • State Poker Guides
      • State Poker Guides
      • California Online Poker Sites
      • Connecticut Online Poker Sites
      • Florida Online Poker Sites
      • Indiana Online Poker Sites
      • Michigan Online Poker Sites
      • Nevada Online Poker Sites
      • Ohio Online Poker Sites
      • Virginia Online Poker Sites
      • Colorado Online Poker
    • Best Online Gambling Sites
      • Best Online Gambling Sites
      • Offshore Gambling Sites
    • Best Online Slots
      • Best Online Slots
      • Betsoft Slots Casinos
      • Danger High Voltage Slot Review
      • Dead or Alive 2 Slot Review
      • Fruit Party 2 Slot Review
      • Gates of Olympus Slot Review
      • Hacksaw Gaming Slots
      • Jammin Jars Slot Review
      • Lil Devil Slot Review
      • Mega Moolah Slot Review
      • Best NetEnt Slots Casinos
      • Sugar Rush Slot Review
      • Sweet Bonanza Slot Review
      • Wolf Gold Slot Review
    • Reviews & Promo Codes
      • Reviews & Promo Codes
      • Lucky Block Crypto Casino & Sportsbook Review
      • How to Buy Bitcoin at Lucky Block
      • Best Football Betting Promo Codes
      • Bovada Bonus Code
      • BetOnline Promo Code
      • Mybookie Promo Codes
      • BetOnline Alternatives
      • Bovada Alternatives
      • BC.Game Alternatives
      • Ignition Casino Bonus Codes
      • Las Atlantis Bonus Codes
      • Lucky Creek Bonus Codes
      • Punt Casino No Deposit Bonuses
      • Roobet Alternatives
      • Best RTG Casinos
      • Stake.com Alternatives
      • Wild Casino Bonus Codes
    • Worldwide Casino Guides
      • Worldwide Casino Guides
      • Bahrain: Online Casinos
      • Brunei: Online Casinos
      • Cambodia: Online Casinos
      • Canada: Online Casinos
      • Canada: New Casinos
      • Canada: Live Casinos
      • Canada: Interac Casinos
      • Canada: Best PayPal Casinos
      • Finland: New Online Casinos
      • Germany: New Online Casinos
      • Hong Kong: Online Casino
      • Hong Kong: Roulette Online
      • India: Online Casino
      • India: Live Casino
      • India: Casino Bonuses
      • India: Live Roulette
      • India: Teen Patti Live Casino
      • India: Andar Bahar Live Casino
      • Indonesia: Online Casino
      • Indonesia: Live Casino
      • Indonesia: Best Casino Welcome Bonuses
      • Indonesia: Dragon Tiger Casinos
      • Ireland: New Online Casinos
      • Israel: Online Casinos
      • Japan: Online Casino
      • Kuwait: Online Casinos
      • Laos: Online Casino
      • Lebanon: Online Casinos
      • Malaysia: Online Casino
      • Malaysia: Live Casino
      • Malaysia: E-Wallet Casinos
      • Malaysia: Online Casino Slots
      • Netherlands: New Online Casinos
      • New Zealand: Best Online Casinos
      • New Zealand: Best Casino Bonuses
      • New Zealand: New Online Casinos
      • New Zealand: Best Mobile Casinos
      • New Zealand: Apple Pay Casinos
      • New Zealand: Real Money Slots
      • Oman: Online Casinos
      • Philippines: Online Casino
      • Philippines: Casino Welcome Bonuses
      • Philippines: Live Casino
      • Philippines: Dragon Tiger Online Casinos
      • Philippines: Jiliko Review
      • Singapore: Online Casino
      • Singapore: Live Casino
      • Singapore: Online Baccarat
      • Singapore: Online Roulette
      • Singapore: Online Slots
      • Singapore: Online Poker
      • Singapore: Mobile Casinos
      • Singapore: Free Credit Online Casinos
      • Singapore: Maxim88 Casino Review
      • Singapore: GemBet Review
      • Singapore: God55 Casino Review
      • South Africa: Best Casino Bonuses
      • South Africa: New Online Casinos
      • South Africa: Bet.co.za Review
      • South Africa: Best Online Slots
      • South Africa: Hollywoodbets Bonus
      • Thailand: Online Casino
      • Thailand: Casino Bonuses
      • Thailand: Huc99 Review
      • UAE: Online Casino
      • UK: Apple Pay Casinos
      • UK: Best Online Casino Sites
      • UK: Fast Withdrawal Casinos
      • UK: New Casino Sites
      • UK: Best Casino Bonuses
      • UK: Best Casino Apps
      • UK: Live Casinos
      • UK: Independent Casinos
      • UK: No Account Casinos
      • UK: Free Casino Bets
      • UK: Neteller Online Casinos
      • UK: Best PayPal Casino Sites
      • UK: Trustly Casinos
      • UK: Online Blackjack
      • UK: Online Roulette
      • UK: Best NetEnt Casinos
      • Vietnam: Online Casino
    • Worldwide Betting Guides
      • Worldwide Betting Guides
      • Belgium: Online Betting
      • Brazil: Sports Betting
      • Brazil: Sports Betting Apps
      • Cambodia: Online Betting
      • Canada: Sports Betting
      • Canada: Sports Betting Apps
      • Hong Kong: Sports Betting
      • Israel: Sports Betting
      • India: Online Betting
      • India: Sports Betting Apps
      • Indonesia: Betting Online
      • Japan: Sports Betting
      • Kuwait: Online Betting
      • Lebanon: Online Betting
      • Malaysia: Online Betting
      • Myanmar: Sports Betting
      • Netherlands: Online Betting
      • New Zealand: Betting Sites
      • Norway: Best Betting Sites
      • Oman: Sports Betting
      • Philippines: Online Betting
      • Philippines: Sports Betting Apps
      • Portugal: Sports Betting Apps
      • Romania: Online Betting
      • Saudi Arabia: Sports Betting
      • Singapore: Sports Betting
      • Singapore: Football Betting
      • Singapore: Horse Betting
      • Singapore: Handicap Betting
      • South Africa: Sports Betting
      • South Africa: Sportingbet Bonus
      • South Korea: Sports Betting
      • Sweden: Betting Sites
      • Taiwan: Sports Betting
      • UAE: Online Betting
      • UK: Best Betting Sites
      • UK: New Betting Sites
      • UK: Horse Racing Betting Sites
    • Worldwide Gambling Guides
      • Worldwide Gambling Guides
      • Canada: Crypto Gambling
      • India: Online Gambling
      • Malaysia: Online Gambling
      • Philippines: Online Gambling
      • Singapore: Online Gambling
      • Taiwan: Online Gambling
      • Vietnam: Online Gambling
      • UK: Online Gambling
      • UK: Crypto Gambling
Countries
  • USA
  • Argentina
  • Bosnia
  • Brasil
  • Čeština
  • Chile
  • Colombia
  • Croatia
  • Danmark
  • Deutschland
  • España
  • Español EE.UU
  • France
  • Indonesia
  • Italia
  • Magyarország
  • Melayu
  • México
  • Nederland
  • Norge
  • Polska
  • Português
  • Perú
  • România
  • Serbia
  • Slovensko
  • Slovenija
  • Suomi
  • Svenska
  • Türkiye
  • Việt Nam
  • Ελληνικά
  • Български
  • Русский
  • ישראל
  • عربي
  • ไทย
  • 한국
  • 中国
  • 日本
Search Business 2 Community
  • Our Cryptocurrency Guides
  • How to Buy Bitcoin – Beginner’s Guide
  • 12 Best Altcoins to Invest in 2023 – Which New Altcoins to Buy?
  • Best Crypto Exchanges 2023
  • 14 Best Crypto Apps for 2023
Digital & Social⟩Online Marketing

Machine Learning for Paid Ads: Best Practices in a New Era

Disclaimer Please note that we are not authorised to provide any investment advice. The information on this page should be construed for information purposes only. We may earn commissions from the products mentioned on this site.
author imageAmanda Evans Last updated: April 16, 2020
Twitter Facebook LinkedIn Flipboard 0

Digital advertising relies on serving the right ad to the right audience in real time. The better we get at that, the better we do—that’s the industry mantra, and for a reason.

We’ve witnessed vast improvements in the volume and accuracy of customer data, and worked in increasingly sophisticated ad platforms.

Machine learning and AI improve the ability to recognize patterns and pull the right responses from a database. Anyone who doesn’t learn to use the AI features of ad platforms now will be left behind. Many already have been.

This means rethinking attitudes, habits, and methods—sometimes profoundly. It ushers in a new era of best practices.

While the space is still evolving, we’ve been in it for a while. These are four keys to take advantage of platforms’ machine-learning capabilities in your campaigns.

1. Use an AI-friendly structure.

In the past, advertisers focused on granularity. “We can account for every penny of spend and show provable ROI”—that was the aim. Now, that same highly granular structure actually limits campaign success.

We have to strike a new balance:

balance of paid account granularity to support ai.

On one side, we have the traditional rewards of higher granularity: higher quality/relevance scores, better insights, and so on. We still want these, but the route we take to them has changed because we’re no longer doing the heavy lifting.

Instead, we’re teaching an AI system to deliver these results for us. All major ad platforms—especially Google and Facebook—use AI to target ads, manage bidding, and budgeting and, increasingly, to optimize creative. To do that quickly and at scale, we often need to sacrifice some granularity. That gives us a data set that can train the AI system faster.

When the balance is struck correctly, results improve drastically—the AI system is more responsive and attentive to data than a human could ever be. What we lose in granularity we make up for in overall accuracy and effectiveness.

Having said that, we still want enough granularity to get some signals about what’s working and what’s not. Selecting destinations is not what AI excels at—we still need to do that.

Take Facebook. Back in 2017, Facebook recommended a highly granular approach:

what campaign setup looked like for paid accounts in 2017.

By 2019, things looked very different—fewer campaigns, fewer ad sets:

facebook campaign structure today.

The rationale for this contraction in ad campaigns and sets—this granularity shrinkage—is that the goal has shifted from “control every penny of spend ourselves” to “rapidly train the AI.”

In the learning phase of AI implementation, you see performance drops of ~30%. Many of the gains we once enjoyed from granularity are eaten at the expense of training the AI. It’s crucial to reduce the duration of this learning phase, which is when you endure the worst performance.

It’s gut-churning to wait it out. But exerting more control (via enhanced granularity) only constricts the incoming data and prolongs the learning phase.

Typically, this updated approach does yield better results. Initially, however, we found it extremely counterintuitive and had to run many experiments to be convinced of its effectiveness.

How does it look outside Facebook? We do our own visualizations, which I’ll introduce to make my point. The size of each box represents spend; color represents ROI—red is bad, blue is good.

If you’d like to see your ad spend visualized this way, check out our free health check app. You can see how your spend looks and what you can do to improve.

What you see in this visualization is a hyper-granular (SKAG) campaign structure in which a small campaign size seems to correlate with poor ROI (lots of small red boxes). The person who crafted this campaign clearly wanted maximum control.

But they’re not getting enough data from smaller campaigns to optimize them in a meaningful way. They’re probably telling themselves that this is by design—that it’s part of a “portfolio management” strategy in which you accept lower performance from a (large) number of campaigns but balance that with higher returns from other areas. It sounds good in principle (and actually used to work that way).

The problem? This isn’t a machine learning–friendly structure. The extreme granularity, in many cases, doesn’t just prolong the learning phase but keeps AI from ever leaving it. With so many variables, the system gets stuck in the learning phase, with profitability forever out of reach.

In fact, over 50% of the ad groups in this visualization had not earned a click in three months but were actively running. Of the remaining 50%, most got no more than five clicks across the same three-month time window—and showed no prospects for growth.

Consolidating spend in areas with a large ROI—and pulling the plug on thousands of tiny, go-nowhere ads—makes sense, with or without AI. But it’s also far better to sacrifice some gains from increased granularity and instead focus on getting the AI to full efficacy faster.

We restructured that campaign to maximize the efficacy for AI, and you can see the difference:

There are still a few smaller ad groups. This isn’t just three big fields. It’s a continuum—not maximum or minimum granularity with nothing in between. But axing thousands of minute, ineffective ads that were impossible to manage trained the AI much faster.

What’s crucial is the degree of granularity in the top 70% of spend volume, which you can see if we stack these two charts on top of each other:

SKAG vs. machine learning structure for ads.

The area outlined in yellow in the top image contains just under 300 ad sets; the one below, 23. Removing low performers from the top 70% led to a radical increase in overall performance.

2. Optimize for the right metrics.

The practical necessities, as well as the advantages, of machine learning have changed how we think about the metrics we optimize for. One of the challenges here is, again, to find the correct balance.

This time, we’re trying to balance funnel depth with data volume. We need enough data to give the algorithm something to learn on and optimize against, but we also want to be as far down the funnel as possible.

traditional sales funnel.

However your “funnel” actually functions—most look like maps of some kind of futuristic metro more than a linear funnel—it’s wider at the top.

Across industries, the conversion rate from MQL to SQL is between 0.9% and 31.0%. Conversion from SQL to customer averages around 22%. But even these sharp bottlenecks pale in comparison to the top of the funnel. The top Google Ads accounts have conversion rates of 11.45%, but the median conversion rate is 2.35%.

The result? We have many more data points at the top of the funnel, so it’s easier to train the AI on that bigger data set. However, success there is not only less valuable but potentially misleading. You can be winning on paper and losing in real life if you’re optimizing for the wrong metric. And TOFU metrics like lead volume or CPL can often be the wrong metrics.

Here’s what we’ve learned trying to find the right balance. A client had been optimizing for CPL/lead volume, shooting for max lead numbers with a $50 per lead cap. We were getting good results.

We were also getting a clear view of which leads were worth buying and which weren’t. We had some leads that were nice leads (i.e. head terms in our space) but too expensive—$100 each in some cases. Why would we spring for those when we had tons of great leads that were $50 or less?

Then, we switched to a metric a couple of steps deeper into the funnel and started optimizing for SQLs. Here are the before-and-after stacked bar charts, with each color area representing a keyword theme:

before and after ad performance based on tracking sqls.

Our low-cost leads that were a “great” value weren’t converting at a worthwhile rate—they were about 40% overpriced. Higher-cost leads were becoming lower-cost SQLs; they paradoxically both cost more money and were cheaper. We maxed those out and saw a sharp increase in profitability.

This insight changed how we allocated spend. SQL volume increased nicely even though lead volume dropped in some cases. That’s hard for some clients to accept at first, but given the choice between more leads and more qualified leads, they opted for the latter.

We never would’ve seen this without optimizing to that lower-funnel metric, but we still wouldn’t have seen it if we weren’t measuring and correlating across the funnel. Measure and optimize multiple metrics, multiple interconnected customer behaviors and actions—not just one. Feeding information from down-funnel to higher-funnel helps targeting, so the leads are better quality to begin with.

Tracking multiple metrics also gives you greater accuracy in the same way that triangulating on distant objects tells you new information, like distance and elevation. Track two, three, five customer data points, and you develop new insights. This isn’t possible without AI because of the enormous number of calculations involved, of course.

Correlating deeper conversion data back to campaign data is a technical challenge, so we’re about to get super geeky with this. Here’s how it’s done with Google:

flow chart for offline conversion tracking.

You patch through the Google Click ID (gclid), let’s say, to your CRM, and record it in the customer database associated with that lead. Then, you feed it back into Google when you’re making ad buy decisions, letting you see which creative, audience, geography, and other variables improve deep-funnel metrics.

But what happens if you switch from optimizing one metric to another? How does your AI implementation manage a new goal?

Managing your AI implementation when KPIs change

What’s weird about this is that it’s a process you kind of feel your way through. When we talk about data-driven marketing, “feel” isn’t a verb you normally hear. But this really is a process of feeling your way to the right outcome. We think of it as “riding the AI beast,” which is a very different and often more intuitive process than “engineering the best ROI.”

Here are a couple of examples. A client wanted to move from optimizing for a top-of-funnel button click to a middle-of-funnel sign-up. We changed the optimization metric in Google and Facebook—and had a very different experience across the two ad platforms.

We’re not saying which is which so as not to offend anyone. And we’ve seen wonky results on both. The point isn’t that one platform is better than the other. The point is that you need to be prepared for unexpected outcomes when dealing with AI.

Here’s the first ad platform:

change in cost per click on a platform after ai implementation.

All we did was flip the switch. We told the AI, “Stop doing that, and start doing this,” and you can see where that happened. Lead volume spiked while CPL dropped. Easy!

Which is cool—when it works. But it doesn’t always come out that way. Here’s the same project, same parameters, but different ad platform:

ai struggling to adjust to changes in ad spend.

This is what it looks like when you can’t just flip the switch. In weeks four and five and, then, in weeks eight and nine, we changed target bids and budgets to boost volume.

However, the algorithm didn’t have the right signals to meet the new bids and budgets, so it simply dropped the volume to almost zero. We tried a bunch of different things until we finally found a combination that let the algorithm function efficiently.

We were riding the beast here, and this likely will be your experience at least some of the time, too.

3. Let AI determine the creative fit.

Is this really a wise idea? We’re not necessarily talking about letting AI actually do creative, but we can use it to fit creative to the audience, sometimes in innovative ways. Let’s run through some examples, starting with responsive search ads.

If you’re not running responsive search ads, I urge you to reconsider—this is where the whole space is going. Google and Facebook already match the ad to the customer automatically. There’s no such thing as a “winning ad” anymore.

When you attempt to manipulate the algorithm to produce a traditional winning ad, you undermine overall performance, sometimes drastically. Even if you manage to produce a winning ad, you have no control over whether it’s shown—the platform makes that decision based on the audience and buyer journey stage.

If you’re not experienced with responsive ads, they work like this: You write pieces of an ad, and then the algorithm assembles them, matching each piece to the audience.

machine learning-driven ad creation.

You can wind up with thousands of variations. It doesn’t make sense to have one definitive combination—a winning ad, as we used to think of it. Here’s how that looks in action on Google Ads:

dynamic ad creation.

Same keyword, same advertiser, same campaign, but two different recipients at two different stages of the buyer journey. That means different ads.

This lets us step back from trying to figure out every tiny detail and refocus on strategic messaging. That can and should still be tested and based on data, we just don’t need to track small-scale, tactical stuff so much.

The downside is that we lose some control. I don’t get a clear beat on the ROI of specific ads, and, obviously, I don’t get a single winning ad. Instead, I get this:

responsive search ad combinations.

So I come out of these campaigns with a feel for overall performance but not the granular insights we’ve come to expect, which circles back to our need to relinquish some control to get this technology to work for us.

The upside is that you can really improve your quality scores. And we’re finding that you can access additional inventory that wasn’t available before with discrete ads.

Here’s what we saw in this case:

responsive ad performance.

Those are giant, not incremental, changes. Assuming you’re doing the basics properly, those kinds of wins are hard to come by with traditional expanded text ads. But with AI steering creative fit, they’re what you should expect.

Responsive ads tend to optimize mostly to CTR, and there’s still no really great way to test them, but they have a positive impact on quality score if you add them to each ad group, and they’re worth using in and of themselves.

Here’s how I recommend getting the best out of them:

  • Use drafts and experiments to test variables.
  • Add additional responsive search ads in each ad group.
  • Use the combinations report to identify segments driving the most and least impressions.
  • Remember that responsive search ads recombine and serve ad elements in real time, so you’ll never be able to put together a true apples-to-apples comparison.
  • Don’t forget to use the ad strength indicator as a baseline.

responsive ad combinations.

4. Follow general guidelines for AI in advertising.

Whatever the specifics of your campaigns, goals, and tools, some rules are broadly true. That’s because they’re dictated by the nature of the available technology and the wider landscape—we don’t have a lot of choice about them.

Structure Keep all match types together, except in extreme cases where volume permits separation. Structure campaigns in a machine learning–friendly way with enough conversions per ad set for the algorithm to learn quickly—ideally 50 per ad group per week on Google, 10 per ad group per week on Facebook.
Measurement Optimize for the right metric, one lower in the funnel but with enough volume.
Creative Use machine learning to reach the right customer with the right ad at the right time. Write different messages to address different phases of the buyer journey.
Audiences Increase audience size. Increase the lookalike audience percentage from 1–5% to 5–15%. Where interest and behavior targets significantly overlap, combine them. Use exclusions to minimize audience overlap.

Conclusion

Putting AI to work in advertising means handing off to machines the tasks that they can do better than we ever could. When it comes to multivariate pattern recognition, machines are already significantly superior to humans.

If you want to match ad elements to the customer journey—or you want to drive radical improvements in CTR and lead price by optimizing for lower-funnel metrics—machines should absolutely be your first choice.

But when we do this, we can’t just give machines part of the job we’re already doing and then carry on as normal. A car is a lot faster than walking, but you have to build a road for it to drive on; machines do this stuff faster and better than we do, but we have to facilitate that work.

There are tasks that machines are either absolutely terrible at or can’t do at all. A machine can mix pre-existing content into novel combinations based on set criteria; it can’t come up with something new. We’re a long way from push-button marketing.

This is the start—of using machine learning for digital advertising, of exploring a wide-open field, and of establishing best practices to guide our industry’s future.

Twitter Tweet
Facebook Share
 Email

  This article was written for Business 2 Community by Amanda Evans.
Learn how to publish your content on B2C

Join our Telegram channel to stay up to date on breaking news coverage

Add B2C to your Google News Feed


author image

Author: Amanda Evans

View full profile ›

Want to list your brand?

Email us

Popular Topics

  • Our Cryptocurrency Guides
  • How to Buy Bitcoin – Beginner’s Guide
  • 12 Best Altcoins to Invest in 2023 – Which New Altcoins to Buy?
  • Best Crypto Exchanges 2023
  • 14 Best Crypto Apps for 2023
  • Best Bitcoin Casino Sites – Compare Bitcoin Casino Sites
  • How To Buy An NFT: The Ultimate Guide
  • Where to Buy Stocks Online
  • Our Spy Guides
  • Our VPN Guides
  • Social Media
  • Marketing
  • Our Gambling Guides
  • Online Casinos Real Money
  • Best Online Sportsbooks
  • Best Offshore Sportsbooks
  • Texas Sports Betting
  • Florida Sports Betting
  • California Sports Betting
  • Best Real Money Casino Apps

  Comments on this article are closed.

Get weekly insider business guides & reviews for free

Join our FREE Telegram Group Now!
Helping Business to Grow since 2011
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Linkedin
    • Crypto News
    • NFT news
    • Best Cryptocurrencies
    • Crypto Wallets
    • NFT Wallets
    • Crypto Exchanges
    • Crypto Gaming
    • Stock News
    • Business News
    • How To Buy Stocks
    • Trading Platforms
    • Trading Robots
    • Forex Brokers
    • What To Invest In
    • Tech News
    • Spy Apps
    • VPN Guides
    • Antivirus Tools
    • VoIP Apps
    • Workflow Tools
    • Accounting Services
    • Online Gambling Sites
    • Best Online Sportsbooks
    • Best Online Casino Sites
    • Sports Betting Apps
    • Bitcoin Casino Sites
    • Crypto Betting Sites
    • Privacy Policy & Terms of Use
    • About B2C
    • Our Editorial Team & Authors
    • Why Trust Us?
    • Editorial Policy
    • Contact Us
Registered Address: Clickout Media Ltd AA PH, Camilleri Buildings, Oratory Street, Naxxar, NXR 2504 Malta Company Number 103525© Business 2 Community. All Rights Reserved.
WARNING: The content on this site should not be considered investment advice and we are not authorised to provide investment advice. Nothing on this website is an endorsement or recommendation of a particular trading strategy or investment decision. The information on this website is general in nature so you must consider the information in light of your objectives, financial situation and needs.

Investing is speculative. When investing your capital is at risk. This site is not intended for use in jurisdictions in which the trading or investments described are prohibited and should only be used by such persons and in such ways as are legally permitted. Your investment may not qualify for investor protection in your country or state of residence, so please conduct your own due diligence or obtain advice where necessary. This website is free for you to use but we may receive a commission from the companies we feature on this site.