In the realm of ATL marketing (Above the Line), marketers advertise the product or the market as a whole. On the other hand, there is also BTL marketing (Below the Line), which is about creating focused communication for a specific customer group.
With consumption trends shifting constantly, marketers need to find ways to address these changing demands. Therefore, there is also TTL marketing (Through the Line), which helps marketers use an integrated approach to advertise products to both mass and focused markets simultaneously.
This article delves into these marketing strategies, outlining how each approach has its unique advantages, challenges, and applications. However, to make the best marketing choices, it’s important to understand the basics (FTC, 2023).
Above the Line (ATL) Marketing
ATL strategies focus on directing communication towards the mass market. All promotional messages are untargeted, meaning they do not focus on a specific target group. The idea behind this is to inform customers about the availability of the product. Marketers seek to encourage customers to visit stores and actively seek out the product. These strategies help companies reach a larger audience and create brand visibility.
Implementing ATL Marketing
- Television: ATL marketing often uses advertising campaigns at regional or national levels. Television’s broad reach ensures maximum exposure, making it a key tool for building brand awareness.
- Print Media: Newspapers, online articles, and ads often feature ATL activities. Print media has a long shelf life, boosting the odds of ads being seen more than once.
- Radio: ATL marketing also uses radio broadcasts across countries or cities. Radio’s auditory format supports creative storytelling, capturing listener attention and leaving a lasting impact.
- Billboards and Outdoor Ads: Big signs placed on highways or busy streets are a type of marketing that reaches a lot of people. They are good for making a brand well-known.
- Transit Advertising: This includes ads on buses, trains, and in stations or airports. The captive audience in these transit spaces can be significant, especially during rush hours.
- Social Media: In the context of ATL marketing, social media platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter are used to reach a broad audience. General campaigns that aim for maximum visibility and brand awareness often employ sponsored posts or ads that appear on users’ feeds, regardless of their specific interests or demographics.
Specific Examples of ATL Marketing
- Television: Coca-Cola often runs holiday-themed commercials during prime time across national networks. These ads aim to evoke emotional connections with a broad audience, reinforcing brand identity.
- Print Media: Bumble recently published a unique print with fake direct messages, showing dating tropes. It uses its visual elements to make itself instantly recognizable.
Source: All Time Design
- Radio: Geico, the insurance company, uses catchy jingles and humorous skits in its radio ads. These ads are broadcast nationwide and aim to be memorable enough to stick in listeners’ minds.
- Billboards and Outdoor Advertising: McDonald’s uses billboards with simple, bold text and imagery, often placed near exits on highways. These billboards aim to entice travelers to take a break and grab a meal.
- Transit Advertising: Companies like Spotify use bus wraps and subway ads to promote their services. These ads are often colorful and feature popular artists, aiming to capture the attention of daily commuters.
Source: Muse by Clio
- Social Media: Nike uses its social media platforms for broad campaigns like the “Just Do It” initiative. These campaigns feature inspirational stories and high-quality visuals, targeting a wide audience to inspire and motivate.
The Alcaraz Era is upon us.
An age in which age doesn’t matter and impossible shots are served with a smile 😏
Congrats Carlos Alcaraz, youngest world no.1, on major no.2.
Your time has only just begun. pic.twitter.com/tY04nrt3of
— Nike (@Nike) July 16, 2023
Advantages of ATL Marketing
- Broad Reach: ATL marketing can reach a large audience, which is good for products with a wide consumer base.
- Cost-Effectiveness: Initial costs can be high. Yet, the cost per impression is often lower due to wide reach.
- Brand Building: ATL marketing helps build brand recognition. It uses catchy jingles, slogans, and visuals.
Challenges and Considerations
- High Costs: Starting an ATL campaign can be expensive. This is true for TV and print ads.
- Lack of Personalization: ATL marketing aims at a wide audience, so messages are not tailored, which may lead to lower conversion rates.
- Measuring ROI: Tracking ROI in ATL marketing can be tough. It’s not as easy as in digital or BTL marketing.
Below the Line (BTL) Marketing
BTL activities are more focused and directed towards specific groups of customers. They are highly targeted, with advertisements being created keeping in mind the demographic and psychographic characteristics of particular customer segments. The communication is highly personalized, and the objective is to gain conversions.
Implementing BTL Marketing
- Outdoor Ads: Billboards and fliers are common in BTL marketing. They are placed in key spots to grab attention.
- Direct Marketing: This includes SMS and emails, with messages being tailored to the recipient.
- Sponsorship: Events offer a channel for BTL marketing, where companies can engage with a niche audience.
- Public Relations: Press events and viral campaigns boost BTL effectiveness.
- In-store Promos: This includes visual displays and samples, engaging customers at the buying point.
- Webinars and Online Workshops: These can be targeted to specific professional groups or consumer interests. They can offer deep dives into topics that resonate with a particular audience.
- Social Media: When used for BTL marketing, social media becomes a highly targeted tool. Platforms offer advanced targeting options, allowing brands to focus on specific age groups, locations, or interests.
- Experiential Marketing: This involves creating immersive brand experiences, like pop-up shops or interactive installations, that engage consumers in a memorable way.
Specific Examples of BTL Marketing
- Outdoor Ads: Planet Fitness uses billboards near offices to attract workers, which use slogans like “Judgment Free Zone.”
- Direct Marketing: Amazon sends you emails based on what you’ve looked at or bought, suggesting other things you might like.
- Sponsorship: Red Bull paid for Felix Baumgartner’s skydive from space. They showed it live online, fitting their brand’s adventurous image.
- Public Relations: When Shake Shack opened in Los Angeles, they invited food bloggers to try their food. This created buzz and attracted local fans.
- In-store Promos: Costco gives out free food samples in the store, often leading to people buying the product right away.
- Webinars: HubSpot offers free online classes on topics like marketing. These are aimed at small business owners and marketing pros.
- Social Media: Airbnb ran a “Live Anywhere” campaign. It was aimed at people who work from home and wanted to change their living situation during the pandemic.
if you’re a…
☑️ remote worker
☑️ empty nester
☑️ digital nomad
or someone who just wants to live anywhere on airbnb, apply now to this program to help inform the future of flexible living. accommodations and travel allowance for 10+ months, on us. 👇 https://t.co/GH0sy53ZHf
— Airbnb (@Airbnb) June 9, 2021
- Experiential Marketing: Samsung set up a pop-up roadshow event to show off their new Galaxy S23 Ultra phone.
Advantages of BTL Marketing
- Trackable Results: BTL marketing allows easy tracking of campaign results, enabling quick adjustments.
- Higher ROI: BTL often yields a higher return on investment than broad marketing.
- Consumer Engagement: BTL uses interactive methods like experiential marketing. This has a strong impact on consumers.
Challenges and Considerations
- Limited Reach: BTL is great for targeting specific groups but less effective for broad outreach.
- Cost Per Engagement: ROI is often higher, but the cost per engagement can be high.
- Resource Intensive: Tailored campaigns need a dedicated team.
Through the Line (TTL) Marketing
TTL marketing involves an integrated approach where both ATL and BTL strategies are combined. The objective here is to get a holistic view of the market and communicate with customers in every way possible. Considering that both ATL and BTL activities are used here, all TTL strategies lead to better brand visibility and brand recall.
Implementing TTL Marketing
- 360-Degree Marketing: Both BTL and ATL marketing are used. For example, a TV ad may come with newspaper pamphlets. This reaches a broad audience.
- Digital Marketing: TTL includes digital channels. This means online banners, social posts, and blogs. They can target specific groups, boosting campaign success.
- Social Media: In a TTL approach, social media serves as a versatile platform that combines the broad reach of ATL with the targeted focus of BTL. Brands may run general awareness campaigns alongside targeted ads aimed at specific customer segments. This dual approach maximizes both reach and engagement.
- Content Marketing: TTL strategies often include a mix of broad-reaching articles and targeted blog posts. This content can be promoted through both ATL and BTL channels, such as social media and email newsletters.
- Influencer Partnerships: Brands can collaborate with influencers who have a wide reach for ATL and those who have a niche but engaged audience for BTL. The combined approach can offer both visibility and targeted engagement.
- Retargeting Campaigns: These campaigns can be broad to re-engage any past website visitors (ATL), but they can also be highly targeted to show specific products or offers based on the individual’s browsing history (BTL).
Specific Examples of TTL Marketing
- 360-Degree Marketing: Coca-Cola’s “Share a Coke” campaign is a great example. They used TV ads to reach lots of people (ATL) and special Coke bottles to connect with individual customers (BTL). They also used social media and hashtags to make it a full-circle approach.
- Digital Marketing: Amazon’s Prime Day is another good example. They use broad ads to tell everyone about the sale (ATL). They also send personalized emails and app alerts based on what you’ve bought before (BTL).
- Social Media: Nike uses social media for both general and targeted ads. They post content that builds their brand and also aim ads at specific groups, like runners or basketball fans.
- Content Marketing: HubSpot offers content for everyone and for niche audiences. They have general articles about marketing (ATL) and also offer specialized guides and webinars for certain industries (BTL).
- Influencer Partnerships: L’Oréal works with both famous people and smaller-scale beauty bloggers. Celebrities help them reach a wide audience (ATL), while smaller influencers connect them with specific groups (BTL).
- Retargeting Campaigns: Airbnb uses retargeting to show you places you’ve looked at before (BTL). They also run general ads to show off popular spots and deals (ATL).
Advantages of TTL Marketing
- Versatility: TTL is flexible, fitt various sectors and audiences.
- Data-Driven: Analytics often measure TTL performance. This data guides future plans.
- Customer Engagement: Multiple channels are used in TTL, boosting the chance of sales.
- Brand Consistency: TTL keeps the brand message the same everywhere, building strong brand identity.
Challenges and Considerations
- High Costs: Diverse ads need big budgets. This often limits TTL to stable companies.
- Complexity: Managing many channels is hard, needing a skilled team.
- Message Dilution: Many channels risk watering down the message.
Final Thoughts on ATL, BTL, and TTL Marketing
There is no one-size-fits-all approach when it comes to marketing. While ATL activities may work for some companies, others may need to supplement it with BTL. Everything depends on how well marketers read the market and whether there is a fit between the customer and the communication.