Cryptocurrency projects with a basis in the Metaverse have been the latest exciting development in the industry. Prominent investors and even large companies are all betting big on this new digital reality. NFT collections offering metaverse experiences are perhaps the most innovative, but it can be extremely difficult to find the best Metaverse NFT projects.
However, we’ve done the research and found 12 of the most exciting projects in the NFT Metaverse. Furthermore, we’ll even be providing a guide covering where and how to buy the best Metaverse NFTs, making the entire process a breeze. Let’s get started.
The 12 Best Metaverse Projects for 2024
For the investors that just need a nudge in the right direction, we’ve included a brief overview of each of the best Metaverse NFT projects. However, comprehensive reviews can also be found just below this section.
- Tamadoge – Overall Best Metaverse Project now on Opensea
- Silks – Best Web3 Fantasy Sports Web3 Game
- Battle Infinity – Top-Rated Metaverse Project
- Real Estate Investment Club – A metaverse for real estate entrepreneurs
- Souls of Nature – Popular Metaverse NFT Project
- MetaCity – NFT Collection from an Established Team
- The Sandbox – Well-Known NFT Metaverse World
- Decentraland – Largest Metaverse Virtual World
- Adidas into the Metaverse – Mainstream Metaverse NFT Project
- Town Star – Metaverse Game from the Creator of Farmville
- DeFi Land – Metaverse Play-To-Earn Farming Game
- Voxels – Voxel Style Metaverse World
- Somnium Space VR – Massively Powerful Programmable Metaverse
A Closer Look at the Metaverse & NFTs
Now that we’ve taken a quick look at the best Metaverse NFT projects, it’s time we take a deeper dive and look at each project individually.
1. Tamadoge – Overall Best Metaverse Project Newly Listed on Opensea
Tamadoge is an NFT-based game currently based in the Tamaverse, a unique and expansive Metaverse world. Tamadoge isn’t just another coin adding to the doge ecosystem; it has utility. It enables players to earn rewards while entertaining themselves, and they do it by raising pets.
Players buy NFTs to feed their pets and also buy toys to entertain them. This crypto game platform ranks players on the leaderboard according to their pet’s development. Players who have developed their pets the most will receive the highest rewards from the prize pool.
Another aspect where Tamadoge differs from a coin such as Dogecoin is that it is a deflationary coin, whereas Dogecoin has increased its supply, Tamadoge’s supply decreases because 5% of all tokens spent are burnt for eternity. Of the remaining 95% of the tokens spent, 65% enter the prize pool and 30% go toward promoting the platform.
The developers introduced an ERC-20 token to ensure coin sales are tax-free and the coin is listed on major centralized exchanges. Solid Proof has audited this project and CoinSniper has verified it.
After selling out its presale and raising an eye-watering $19 million far ahead of schedule, Tamadoge has gone on to increase in value exponentially. The TAMA token was listed on the centralized exchange OKX and is currently trading for $0.093, marking over a 300% increase from its listing price and more than a 900% increase from its lowest presale price.
While TAMA has already been enjoying increased demand, the October 6th release of the first Tamadoge NFT collection is likely to boost things even further. Later down the line, Tamadoge will also release 1,000 rare and 20,000 common NFTs for use within the P2E game.
The drop will see 100 ultra-rare Tamadoge NFTs released boasting increased stats. Each of these ultra-rare NFTs will be usable in the upcoming P2E game. With the project’s core features slowly rolling out, it could be the perfect time to invest in Tamadoge. Check out the project today to get involved before the upcoming NFT drops push prices higher.
TAMA NFTs are now live to buy on Opensea.
2. Silks – Best Web3 Fantasy Sports Web3 Game
Silks is the world’s first derivatives play-to-earn metaverse that mirrors the real world of Thoroughbred horse racing. The platform bridges the gap between the real and crypto worlds by linking NFT Silks Horses derivatives to real-world racehorses. So if you own the NFT of the horse that wins in actual races, you are rewarded in the Silks metaverse.
The ecosystem works by taking the real-world data and statistics of living thoroughbred racehorses and linking them to the NFTs. For example, data such as bloodline, training progress, and racing results are inputted into the NFTs.
The diverse ecosystem of Silks is comprised of the following types of NFTs;
- Racing Silks Avatars
- Silks Horses
- Silks Land
- Silks Stables
The Racing Silks Avatars are digital uniforms representing the identity of individual racehorse owners. They are required to participate in the ecosystem and start earning rewards as they allow holders to mint their first NFT Horses and access the metaverse.
The first drop from the 10,000 collection of Silks Avatars were quickly bought up by top investment firms and NFT communities – including Bored Ape Yacht Club NFT holders. Furthermore, it became a top #10 ranked Sports NFT on OpenSea and was listed on the prestigious Nansen.ai 50 Gaming Index.
Owning one of these Avatars provides the following benefits in the Silks ecosystem;
- The ability to mint a Silks Horse NFT each year.
- Provides an avatar to access the metaverse.
- Allows owners to collect racing rewards.
- Inherit a Sky Falls Genesis parcel claim of land in the metaverse 45 days after holding the Avatar in the same wallet.
- Gain access to exclusive experiences, giveaways, and in-person events.
The collection of 10,000 NFTs is over 65% sold out, so you’ll have to be quick to purchase an NFT. After that, the only option will be to buy the Silks Avatars from other users on secondary markets such as Open Sea. You can currently buy one of the remaining Avatars for a price of 0.25 ETH.
Once you have a Silks Avatar, you will be able to mint one of the Silks Horses, which are 1:1 replicas of real-world thoroughbred horses. If your horse wins in its races (or produces offspring of its own), you are rewarded in the Silks metaverse.
As Silks mirrors the Thoroughbred horse racing industry, the potential for the ecosystem is quite vast. The industry generates $11 billion in the US annually and does well in all marketing conditions – including recessions. In fact, 2022 has been a record-breaking year for Thoroughbred Horse Sales and prize purses.
As a result, the Silks Horses could become very valuable down the line, especially if you own one of the top-ranked real-world horses. The whitepaper estimates that yearlings, horses that turn one year old, have an average auction sale price of $60,000. As the NFTs are derivatives of real horses, we could expect their value to increase dramatically as the project matures. Still, you first need to own one of the Silks Avatars to be able to mint a Silks Horse – so pick one up today before they are totally sold out.
3. Battle Infinity – Top-Rated Metaverse Project
Do you know how to invest in the metaverse in 2024? Developers of Battle Infinity ensured they offered numerous benefits by combining the Metaverse with gaming elements to create an NFT fantasy sports game. Besides earning rewards, players can build teams and use VR head devices to walk in the Metaverse and meet other players to chat in real-time.
As one of the best metaverse games on the market in 2024, players have access to six platforms such as Battle Stake, Battle Arena and Battle Swap. But to take advantage of this ecosystem, players need to buy IBAT, the platform’s token. They can do it on Battle Swap, enabling players to exchange their rewards from the platform to other currencies. A portion of the transaction fees on the platform go to the global staking pool, which distributes rewards to active players.
Battle Market attaches a value to assets and characters within this platform that the gaming industry may not do, so players can reap rewards. Staying up to date is best achieved via the Telegram group, and investors should act on an opportunity that shows tremendous growth potential.
The Battle Infinity presale sold out just 24 days after launch and has since seen pumps after listings on PancakeSwap and LBank. With a current market cap of $40 million – and more listings in the pipeline – Battle Infinity is expected to see more price pumps in the coming weeks and months.
4. Real Estate Investment Club – A metaverse for real estate entrepreneur
Real Estate Investment Club is an NFT collection consisting of NFTs created by some of the designers from the GTA and Red Dead Redemption teams. The NFTs serve as your access and avatar to the REIC – MetaCity, a metaverse dedicated to real estate education and investing. The NFTs also grant holders access to the Digital Asset Property Group (DAPG).
REIC – MetaCity is a high-definition metaverse created using Unreal Engine 5, the same gaming engine used to create Fortnite. This means that the metaverse will be highly polished with lifelike animations. Just take a look at the teaser trailer below;
REIC… #NFT #NFTS pic.twitter.com/7w9Ib7xEwT
— Real Estate Investment Club (@REIC_io) July 25, 2022
The team behind REIC intends to construct its own Metaverse-as-a-Service (MaaS) to act as the virtual city for all REIC members. Players can monetize their assets and services inside the metaverse to create an in-game economy to earn money.
The center of the metaverse will house the REIC HQ building, designed by a team of architects and developers. There, the team will host regular meetups and education services, provide future investment opportunities, and grant REIC members access to industry elites for personal mentorship in real estate investing.
Holding the REIC NFTs grants certain utilities besides accessing the metaverse itself. For example, the team has plans to host private real-world events for REIC members in premium locations – the first being in Edinburgh.
There are also a host of giveaways lined up that include;
- Minting female REIC avatars
- Future REIC NFT airdrops
- REIC merch giveaways
- Consultation and investment advice from industry elites
- Webinar/Seminar access
- Holidays in premium locations
- Luxury items such as watches and cars
- Charitable donations
One of the best giveaways is the Ethereum down payment contribution for your first real estate investment.
The main goal of REIC – MetaCity is for it to act as the pioneer in bringing real estate investments to the blockchain. The team believes that real estate will soon be widely tokenized with ownership shares represented on the blockchain. Therefore, they intend to provide the necessary infrastructure required to be the leading community in real estate investment.
The NFTs are expected to be minted at some point in September 2022.
5. Souls of Nature – Popular Metaverse NFT Project
Souls of Nature is an upcoming new NFT project that is aiming to shake up the current Metaverse landscape. It is also one of the best utility NFT projects on the market as of 2024. The collection consists of 9,271 NFT animals that act as an avatar within the Metaverse.
Play-to-Earn games are quickly growing in popularity but most titles are basic and offer little in terms of user experience. Souls of Nature is aiming to disrupt the status quo by using Unreal Engine to create a one-of-a-kind experience. By implementing market-leading technology into the project, Souls of Nature is set to create a truly immersive experience for its users. The experience will involve the user going on a quest to rescue the endangered world and will be the first HD Metaverse of its kind. Crypto investors who want to gain exposure to the best metaverse coins in 2024 can read our useful article right now.
As Souls of Nature is dedicated to helping the world and protecting Mother Nature, the team has pledged that a percentage of the funding raised by the initial collection will be donated to protect endangered ecosystems. With the negative sentiment surrounding NFTs and electricity usage, this seems like a great way of giving back and improving the world around us.
Souls of Nature has a clear roadmap and well-defined plans for the future. The experience-to-earn demo is due to be released soon and give users a better understanding of how the game will work. Later, the team plans on developing an in-game marketplace that will enable users to buy/sell items using the upcoming $ZOOIE currency.
Overall, Souls of Nature is a wildly interesting NFT collection that is set to make a positive impact on the real world. While the project is still in its early stages, it shows massive promise.
Cryptoassets are a highly volatile unregulated investment product.
6. MetaCity – NFT Collection from an Established Team
Part of the Humans of the Metaverse NFT (HOTM) collection, MetaCity is a virtual world in which HOTM holders will be able to spend $HOTM and interact with other users in several exciting ways. The collection consists of virtual plots that users can build on top of.
Similar to The Sandbox or Dencentraland, MetaCity will allow users to create their own experiences on the platform, meaning the platform has a near-unlimited amount of potential.
During the first quarter of 2022, MetaCity held a land sale for the plots that users can build on. While the collection sold out quickly, it’s still possible to buy land on secondary markets like OpenSea, meaning there’s still plenty of room for new users. As the city expands, the team plans on adding a series of new features like a ‘bank’ which will act as a Decentralised Autonomous Organisation, and a ‘museum’ which will function as an NFT launchpad for upcoming artists to make a name for themselves.
The project is already in full swing and with a clear roadmap covering the rest of the year, it seems like the development team has a solid plan for the future. Furthermore, the team has a great track record. The original Humans of the Metaverse collection sold out in just 14 minutes and for investors worrying about the Metaverse NFT price, the collection starts at just 0.013 ETH.
MetaCity is a fairly new but extremely exciting project. While it’s still relatively early in the project’s development things are moving quickly and the future seems bright.
Cryptoassets are a highly volatile unregulated investment product.
7. The Sandbox – Well-Known NFT Metaverse World
The Sandbox is one of the most famous Metaverses in existence. It’s garnered attention from prominent figures in the crypto community as well as well-known businesses. There are a massive number of NFTs within The Sandbox ecosystem, including both wearables and plots of virtual land.
As The Sandbox is largely a user-created experience (other than the initial infrastructure), the only limit is the player’s imagination. Almost anything is possible in The Sandbox, from NFT Metaverse casinos to interactive games, and even fairground rides. This gives The Sandbox a massive amount of replayability and provides users even more of a reason to buy SAND over the long term.
The Sandbox provides users with the tools it needs to create on the platform. This means the players fuel the game’s economy and that the amount of cosmetics within the game will continue growing. Users can create buildings, attractions, and wearables like jumpers, so there’s a massive amount of possibilities.
To help reward creators for choosing The Sandbox as their Metaverse of choice, people can sell their creations on the in-game marketplace and earn funds that can then be exchanged for fiat. Additionally, users can monetize the attractions they can be doing things like charging entry fees or even adding play-to-earn elements to their own minigames.
All in all, The Sandbox is more than just another game. It gives users the tools to create almost anything. With hundreds of thousands of NFTs in The Sandbox ecosystem, it’s clear the project is resonating with players and will likely continue to do so.
Cryptoassets are a highly volatile unregulated investment product.
8. Decentraland – Largest Metaverse Virtual World
Decentraland is The Sandbox’s largest competitor. It follows a very similar model and also offers an NFT Metaverse-based virtual world for users to explore and create. For those interested, we’ve got a great article covering where to buy MANA, the currency native to Decentraland.
The Decentraland ecosystem is home to over 100,000 NFTs that take the form of both wearables and plots of land. Users can purchase land and build experiences on it similarly to The Sandbox. However, Decentraland has somewhat of a more corporate feel as more companies have made it home in comparison to The Sandbox.
The Decentraland economy is again fuelled by players and it’s buzzing. With MANA being the 33rd largest cryptocurrency on CoinMarketCap, it’s clear that investors have high hopes for the NFT real estate Metaverse. Although it’s slightly larger than The Sandbox in terms of price, both are leading Metaverses that are worthy of investment.
9. Adidas into the Metaverse – Mainstream Metaverse NFT Project
The Adidas into the NFT Metaverse collection made headlines during releases and it’s no surprise why. The project was created as a collaboration between the most expensive NFTs, including the Board Ape Yacht Club, CryptoPunks, and of course, Adidas. With such influential names behind the collection, it’s of little surprise the collection has a floor price of 1.2 ETH.
When the project was originally released it granted the holders to physical merch linked to the NFT they owned. Although the window to claim this merch has now closed, Adidas is working on phase 2 of the project which will likely breathe new life into the collection and reward loyal holders.
Along with real-life merch, the Adidas into the Metaverse collection also provided the owners with virtual experiences and wearables in the Metaverse. The collection has a massive amount of hype behind it and it’s likely the second phase will perform even better than the first.
10. Town Star – Metaverse Game from the Creator of Farmville
Town Star is a competitive blockchain-based farming game that follows a similar model to the massively successful Farmville franchise. It was built by Gala Games on the Ethereum network and centers around creating a farm, using NFT-based items in a virtual world.
Town Star was created by one of the co-founders of Zynga (the company behind Farmville) so it’s no wonder that the Town Star blockchain game has managed to capture so much attention. As stated on the Town Star website, over 600 million people play farming games so if Town Star is able to capture just a fraction of those users, it could become the largest Metaverse crypto game on the market.
Although Town Star has a long way to go before it can be considered a competitor to Farmville, with the rate at which the crypto industry is growing, it could hit this goal sooner than anyone expects
11. DeFi Land – Metaverse Play-To-Earn Farming Game
Another project aiming to capture some of the farming game magic is DeFi Land. In contrast to most crypto games, DeFi Land features both free and paid options, meaning users aren’t forced to spend large sums just to begin playing.
The game features play-to-earn elements that reward users for completing a wide range of actions in the game. On top of its play-to-earn mechanics, DeFi Land also aggerates different staking protocols allowing users to manage a variety of assets on a single platform. While the Metaverse elements of DeFi Land are still in their early stages, plots of land for the game’s virtual world have already been sold. Soon, users will be able to build and develop their plots similarly to Decentraland.
DeFi Land takes a similar approach to Town Star but has put a slightly greater emphasis on the Metaverse. It’s a well-designed project with a clear development roadmap.
12. Voxels – Voxel Style Metaverse World
As the name implies, Voxels is a voxel-based metaverse world. It’s similar to The Sandbox but features a more Roblox-esque design. Furthermore, Voxels has a greater emphasis on the NFT real estate Metaverse side of things.
The Voxels world is split into a series of land plots named similarly to real-life streets (e.g. Polk Street). This gives the Voxels world a more homely feel in comparison to platforms like Decentraland. Users can build, develop, and sell their virtual properties just like real-world real estate. For anyone wanting to get involved with Voxels, the Metaverse NFT floor price is currently 0.743 ETH.
While Voxels is lagging behind the big names in terms of technology, the team is working to make it a leading Metaverse experience and with a trading volume of over 25,000 ETH, it seems people have faith in the project.
What are Metaverse NFTs?
There is no single Metaverse. Every project will have its own virtual world, meaning there can be a lot of differences between each. As such, the NFT Metaverse falls into a wide range of categories. It can include Metaverse casino NFTs, augmented reality experiences, and even the NFT real estate Metaverse. While each of these kinds of projects does fulfill very different objectives, at its core, each involves some kind of interactive virtual world and that is what defines a Metaverse NFT.
Are Metaverse NFTs a Good Investment?
NFTs and the Metaverse go together like bread and butter. Because of this, there are a lot of great projects cropping up that have loads of potential; Souls of Nature for example.
Unfortunately, with there being so many projects it’s impossible to say that every Metaverse NFT is a good investment. However, there are a few factors that anyone can analyze in order to help them determine whether a cool NFT project is worthy of investment
Track Record – One of the easiest ways to determine how likely an NFT Metaverse is to survive is by taking a look at the team behind it. If the people running a project have a proven track record of delivering on their claims and creating value for investors, it’s a good indicator of the project’s validity.
Roadmap – The best Metaverse NFT projects will always have a clearly defined roadmap. This tells investors that the team has planned ahead, estimated how long development will take, and most importantly, that they’re transparent about the project.
Plans for the Future – Linking into the roadmap, it’s always worth checking what a project has planned for the future. While it’s easy to get caught up in the now, the best Metaverse NFT projects will provide long-term value. Seeing how a team plans to develop the project over the long run can provide good insight into whether it’ll actually last or fade away shortly down the line.
Technology – As both NFTs and Metaverse are still fairly new, emerging technologies, it’s worth seeing if a project’s claims are within the realm of possibility. Of course, most projects develop their own technology to some extent, if something sounds too ambitious to be true it probably is.
Where to Buy Metaverse NFTs
Figuring out where to buy the best Metaverse NFT projects is one of the most important aspects of the entire process. To make things easier, we’ve included reviews for a couple of the best marketplaces out there.
1. NFT LaunchPad
NFT LaunchPad is a fairly young platform, launched in February 2022. However, don’t let its age fool you, the platform is well-designed, powerful, and has some great NFT collections. Namely, the Lucky Block Platinum High Rollers Club which provides holders with daily chances to win big prizes.
The NFT Launchpad marketplace supports collections created using both the Binance Smart Chain (BSC) and Polygon (MATIC) networks. Because of this, there are plenty of cheap NFT projects to choose from. The platform uses Wrapped BNB (WBNB) as its native currency meaning all transactions on the marketplace benefit from low fees, making it far easier to snag a deal.
It’s possible to mint NFT collections in a variety of formats. This means users can create animated, audio, and still NFTs. On top of this, anyone minting their own collection has total control over things like assigning rarities and changing royalties. Furthermore, creators can also benefit from the ability to create a dedicated NFT page for a collection that contains important information like key links and a description of the project.
With the rate at which NFT LaunchPad is growing, it’s only a matter of time before it becomes a leading name in the NFT space. Therefore, there’s no better time to get to grips with the marketplace. It’s intuitive and navigation is simple, meaning getting started takes next to no time. Every key button is clearly signposted and important information is easy to find. Overall, it’s an excellent marketplace for buyers, sellers, and creators. Whatever your needs, it’s hard to go wrong with NFT Launchpad.
Pros Cons
Your capital is at risk.
2. Crypto.com
Crypto.com is famous for being one of the best crypto exchanges on the market but in 2021, the titan decided to make a move into the NFT space. The exchange launched the Crypto.com NFT marketplace and as expected, it quickly built up traction.
One of the main draws to the Crypto.com NFT marketplace is its extremely low fees. In fact, there are no fees at all for buying NFTs on the marketplace. However, there is a small 1.99% fee for creators that want to mint and sell on the platform, as well as a 1.99% fee for secondary sales.
There is a wide variety of NFTs available on the Crypto.com marketplace. The platform supports multiple formats so it’s possible to find anything from regular NFT art to more complex animated collections. The marketplace currently supports NFTs created on the Ethereum, Polygon, Solana, Cronos, and Crypto.org chains so there’s plenty of choice.
The marketplace has a simple-to-navigate interface and uses the familiar Crypto.com color scheme. It’s easy to search for specific NFTs and with the diverse range of filters available, finding a collection that meets specific requirements is a breeze.
All in all, the Crypto.com marketplace has a lot going for it. There are thousands of NFTs available on the platform, including notable collections like the PSG x Jay Chou collection. Combine these factors with the brand’s track record of providing an excellent user experience and the Crypto.com marketplace is a great choice for anyone looking for the best Metaverse NFT projects.
Pros Cons
Your capital is at risk.
How to Buy Metaverse NFTs
While it can be difficult to work out how to buy Metaverse NFTs, by following the steps below, investors of all experience levels can get set up quickly and without hassle.
Step 1 – Create a Wallet
Before it’s possible to buy any NFTs, a crypto wallet must first be created. Thankfully, the process is simple and takes only a few minutes. Just download a wallet app or extension, we recommend MetaMask. Then, follow the on-screen instructions to create the wallet.
Step 2 – Buy Crypto
Once the wallet has been created, it’s time to buy some BNB. This can be done through either an exchange or a regulated broker like eToro. The BNB purchasing process is simple enough but it might still be worth checking out our how to buy Binance Coin guide. After the BNB has been purchased, ensure the newly created wallet is set to the Binance network and then transfer over the assets.
Cryptoassets are a highly volatile unregulated investment product. No UK or EU investor protection.
Step 3 – Connect Wallet
After the funds have arrived in the MetaMask wallet, the next step is connecting to NFT LaunchPad. Simply head over to the NFT LaunchPad website, press the purple button with a wallet icon, hit the MetaMask icon, and confirm the connection using the MetaMask wallet.
Step 4 – Buy Metaverse NFTs
Now that the MetaMask wallet has been connected to NFT LaunchPad, it’s possible to buy an NFT. Just click on the search bar, enter the name of the collection, choose an NFT, press the purple ‘Buy’ button, double-check the details, and press ‘Pay’. The funds will be taken and the NFT will be transferred to the connected wallet.
Conclusion
Throughout this guide, we’ve taken a look at some of the best Metaverse NFT projects on the market and provided an easy-to-follow rundown on how to buy an NFT. Each of the collections we’ve looked at has merit, but one stood out from the rest.
Tamadoge is an exciting project that combines play-to-earn gaming and NFT ownership with a metaverse and meme coin potential for growth. Souls of Nature is another Metaverse experience-to-earn NFT collection that has the potential to drastically shake up the sector. The project has a great team behind it, a clear roadmap, and a demo coming soon.
For those looking for the next cryptocurrency or NFT to explode in 2024 it’s worth checking out Lucky Block. As one of the first blockchain-based play-to-earn platforms, many crypto-hungry traders are keeping a close eye on LBLOCK.
Next NFT to Blow Up - Lucky Block
- #1 NFT Competitions Platform - luckyblock.com
- Daily NFT Jackpot Draws - Free Entry
- Lifetime Platinum Rollers Club Benefits
- LBLOCK Token Listed on LBank, Gate.io, MEXC, PancakeSwap (V1 Token)
- 10,000 NFTs Minted - nftlaunchpad.com
Tamadoge - The Play to Earn Dogecoin
- '10x - 50x Potential' - CNBC Report
- Deflationary, Low Supply - 2 Billion
- Listed on Bybit, OKX, Bitmart, LBank, MEXC, Uniswap
- Move to Earn, Metaverse Integration on Roadmap
- NFT Doge Pets - Potential for Mass Adoption
FAQs
Are NFTs part of the metaverse?
What is the best metaverse NFT project?
How do I get metaverse NFTs?
Can you make money with metaverse NFTs?
Read more:
- Meta to Add NFTs to Instagram, Facebook in May
- Best NFT Games to Play & Top Upcoming NFT Games
- Best NFT Presales to Invest in 2024