Subscription Box Talk

We sat down with three of the most popular subscription box reviewers to get their thoughts on some of the most common questions new (and even seasoned) box owners have about packing, presentation, and getting publicity. Including in the interview is Wendy, who runs Two Little Rosebuds, Brandy, who runs Hello Subscription, and Liz, who runs My Subscription Addiction.

We sourced out questions from existing business owners, prospective business owners, and from some FAQs we hear about the review and publishing process.



How important is custom packaging to you?

Wendy: Honestly, if the items inside are awesome I really don’t give much thought to the packaging itself. Of course, if I receive a box that’s beautifully presented I’ll definitely take note of that and mention it in the review. One thing I hate to see is a company that spends a lot on custom packaging and then allows the contents to suffer. I recently received a new box (I won’t mention any names!) that was impressive on the outside but VERY underwhelming once opened. Custom packaging is nice, but actual curation is what I base my reviews on.

Brandy: It’s not essential (except for really luxe boxes), but I like to see a little decoration on the boxes. If you’re using some type of decoration, it seems like you should just get custom packaging – probably about the same cost. In reviews, I definitely will not take a picture of the box if it’s ugly. I also hate the box that I can’t compost because of their inks.

Liz: I think packaging is important, especially for subscription boxes. They’re meant to feel special and you want that experience to start as soon as you see the box. The other thing that’s important is that its professional feeling. You’re letting customers know you’re professional.

Does having really nice inserts, etc, add value in your opinion?

Wendy: I wouldn’t say that it adds value, per say. It definitely makes for a more pleasant unboxing experience, but like I said about the custom boxes — it’s all about the contents.

Brandy: If it’s really nicely done, I like them. One box I get has an illustrator design the card each month; it’s really nice and framable. For people like me, that’s a cool add.

Liz: I do like cards and nice prints; something like a postcard is a cool addition sometimes. It does at some specialness to the box. Just don’t put a price on it! That can spoil the experience.


How does/when does curation to trump value?

Wendy: “Overall value” is always a tricky thing to determine with subscription boxes. Especially when it comes to handcrafted/artisan/“niche” items. If it looks like a lot of work/care was put into curating a box to say, a specific theme, I definitely take that into consideration. Some boxes are more about convenience/saving time than “getting your money’s worth” and I try to get that across in my reviews.

Brandy: Personally, I think it depends on the vertical. For example, if it’s an artisan food box, I think as long as the contents are worth the price + shipping it’s a good value. Kids box might not need to have the whole value in there, as long as the kids love the contents. If it’s not unique and doesn’t solve a big pain point for people, then I think it really needs to be focused on providing cash value.

Liz: For the vast majority of our readers, the value is at the top of the list in terms of importance. Curation is important too, but a typical reader would be looking for value. There’s a market for it, but there’s not a large market.

Do the number of items matter to you each month if it’s the same value?

Wendy: It depends. Generally, I’d say no. However, for something like a snack box I’d much rather receive a variety of smaller (lower value) snacks to try than to get a full-sized item that I may not even like (thus receiving less items to make up the cost of the larger one).

Brandy: Well, it’s hard to feel worth it if the box feels empty, and don’t use cheap filler to try to make it feel full. That stuff gets everywhere.

Liz: It’s an interesting question. On the one hand, if there 5 items that are evenly valued, there still feeling good about that box if one of those items is off. On the other hand, if you have 1 really high value item and 2 lesser value items, then it’s risky. It might feel empty, and more risky is that if someone doesn’t like the high priced item, then the box feels like a waste. I think it’s a good idea to do a spoiler of the high value item if you have a low quantity box with 1 high value item.

Do monthly “themes” matter to you/add to the experience?

Wendy: I’m sort of a sucker for a good theme. Especially when they involve holidays/seasonal-related items. So, yes. Bring on the themes!

Brandy: I don’t care if there isn’t a theme, but I like it if it’s a good idea and related to the box. I do like sharing theme sneak peeks, so it’s a way for them to get a little more exposure. If you do a theme, make sure it makes sense with the products.

Liz: I don’t think you need to do it, but it can help and it gets people excited. They’re great for spoilers. If you use one, just don’t be too specific – use basic overall themes. I think they’re a fun way to experience a box if done well.


If you had two similar boxes from different companies, what would you look for when choosing one over the other?

Wendy: As a customer, price. I’d look for a coupon code or some kind of promo offer and choose the one with the most savings.

Brandy: Frankly, it’s a “do I personally like this stuff or less than the other companies?” question. It’s really about what I use more, what I enjoy, did I value the experience, etc.

Liz: Based on past boxes/reviews a lot of the time. Exclusive items can really move the needle. Ie. New released books, new book goodies, some type of exclusive content.

What do the best boxes consistently do to impress you?

Wendy: Continually send high-quality, well made products at a reasonable monthly cost. It’s really just that simple. :)

Brandy: I love when companies create fun monthly expectations of things. I like how some companies have used a monthly shirt in their boxes; it makes sense because their subscribers value it and it gives them all something to look forward to. Also, I really am impressed when I use everything from a box. Even if it’s not a “Wow!” Experience, I think being able to use everything is always impressive.

Liz: I think the element of surprise is a big part of it. I love boxes that have items you wouldn’t normally come across. Something newly launched, limited edition, or otherwise uniquely special. Consistent value is also awesome. I also really like when my favorite boxes do limited edition boxes because I can gift those to friends and family.

Have you ever tried a box when they just launched? What did they do to impress you/attract your readers?

Wendy: Yes, quite a few. I’m usually impressed by boxes that are unique or have something different to offer customers. Snack and beauty boxes are great, but it’s exciting to get a box that falls into a category all of its own. I’d say readers generally feel the same. Offering some kind of discount or special offer is always a good idea to attract new customers. If I don’t have a coupon code to publish with a review of a new box, I often get asked if they have one available. People are all about getting good deals.

Brandy: I feel like nothing gimmicky really works. You just need to appear high quality. Keep expectations in line with us reviewers too. When you’re just launching, we know it’s important to you but we already review a lot of boxes. It will take us a few weeks to review your box.

Liz: Well, we’re always hesitant with a first-time box. They need to assure us that stock and inventory is going to be there. They might get a big bump from us, then not be able to meet those expectations, which is bad for our readers. I also suggest that once they launched, we do one or two reviews, then we have a conversation about advertising – not sooner than that. Other than that, I think the best launches have been the ones that look professional with nice photos that help assure customers the box is going to be great. New boxes tend to be using stock photos, and I feel like it’s a bit cheesy and makes them less likely to be successful.


What is something all subscription boxes could do to make your job easier?

Wendy: Include info cards!! I get a LOT of boxes for review, so anything that saves me from having to look up product descriptions and retail prices on my own is MUCH appreciated. (Just don’t inflate the prices!)

Brandy: Put a piece of collateral in box! A packing list, a welcome card, anything. I do not like digital packing lists, because sometimes you don’t know if something is something supposed to be there. Also, put less squiggles (kraft paper) in the boxes.

Liz: Okay, I’d answer this in two parts, one for the customer and one for me as a reviewer. For the customers, 1) Make sure it’s clear when people get the box. “If I sign up today, will I get this box?” Is our number one question. 2) Make sure your FAQs really answer FAQs. Sometimes they’re branded questions, which is okay, but you need to make sure your basic info is clear. 3) If you’re a new box, make sure your social media and contact information is accurate and accessible.

For reviewers, there are definitely some things I’d suggest. 1) When a person sees a review of a new box, a lot of time they tell us “Future reviews will make me decide,” so please keep sending boxes! I think a lot of boxes think it’s one-and-done with reviewing. 2) Keep us and your customers updated on shipping timelines and if something is going to be late. Just send an email! 3) The packing list needs to be there. We want something to reference even if we don’t always read the whole card.

How can someone tell the difference between a “good” reviewer with real influence and a “poor” reviewer with little influence?

Wendy: Most people would say the number of readers/followers they have and where they rank in Google, but I don’t necessarily agree. Yes, having SEO power is good, but the quality of the content is sometimes lacking on a lot of “bigger” sites. It’s easy to tell when a reviewer “phones it in”. (Obvious typos, nonsensical sentences, poor photos, very short reviews, etc.) Also, when a review site gets really popular, they often end up farming their reviews out to other people (which isn’t necessarily bad), but then there’s never a consistent voice for the readers or the companies sending in their boxes for review.

Brandy: First, read their reviews. Find a real reviewer who seems like a real customer you might have. You need to find a good fit. Once you do, vet them so you know their quality and if they are right for you. Maybe find a similar blog with similar numbers and try to match and compare them.

Liz: Look at their social media metrics and look at their engagement. You should also look at something similar to your business on their site. If they reviewed a similar product, you should be able to see some engagement around it. Maybe reach out to the company and ask for their results. Hopefully they’re willing to share some info with you!

Have More Questions for Subscription Box Bloggers?

We’ll be updating this piece with additional interviews with other bloggers and reviewers, so make a point to come back to catch the updates. If you have more questions, post them in the comments below for the opportunity for them to be added to the list.

A special thanks to Wendy, Brandy and Liz for contributing their answers!