Analysis of global conversations offer software giant new insights on Nokia, brands, and merger
The deal is done. After nearly a year of negotiation and speculation, Microsoft announced its acquisition of Nokia’s mobile phone and device business on April 25th. The $7.2 billion transaction is intended to bring Microsoft’s Windows 8 operating system to their leading hardware supporter, Nokia. As a result, Microsoft’s mobile phone market position is expected to enter a new era. Welcome to the world of Microsoft Mobile.
As 30,000+ former Nokia employees are in the midst of crossing over to Microsoft, millions are logging onto Twitter to share their two cents on the acquisition. We sought out the public’s response to the Microsoft Mobile rebrand, comparing the past perceptions of Nokia brand to those of its new name. We found that the Nokia brand is often associated with the past, which is limiting consumer excitement for the future.
To understand what kind of sentiment Nokia is bringing to Microsoft’s table, we start with an opinion breakdown over the past year.
Between April 2013 and the end of April 2014, 66% of Twitter posts expressed negative sentiment toward Nokia Mobile. Our biggest takeaway is how old-school Nokia technology is perceived to be in the eyes of the public. 40% of conversation showed that the public still considers Nokia to be a brand of dated mobile devices, offering phones that serve only as a last resort. Low-quality percentages beat out high-quality percentages, and the usability numbers were no different. These results suggest that Nokia never truly separated themselves from their iconic 1990’s phone models, such as the Nokia 100. Remember using one of those?
For example, a buyer may pass on a Nokia Lumia Smartphone because it came from “those” guys. The guys who brought you T9word texting and the pixelated “Snake” to pass the time. The generations that saw mobile phone technology develop since its birth may identify Nokia with the industry’s first baby steps and put a successful Smartphone beyond the company’s potential.
This Microsoft/Nokia thing is what happens when you're not innovative. I'm all for old-school/vintage, but a brand's gotta keep up
— Olutayo (@wyredboi) April 25, 2014
@nokia No matter how many good handsets they churn out, Microsoft-Nokia shall never be considered as cool as Nokia in its hay day.
— Satya Swaroop Dash (@thecooldesiboy) April 25, 2014
Microsoft sees things differently. The #MoreColorful campaign is underway, and rebranding Nokia technology is Microsoft’s next big advertising expenditure. Excited by the potential of their acquisition, top management has cited that past models like the Lumia 920 are a testament to the good that the two companies can do together.
Microsoft and Nokia collaborated on the Nokia 920 back in 2012. Of 351,000 relevant blogs, tweets, forums, and Facebook posts since its launch, only 8% reveal negative opinion of the product. To put this in perspective, 17% of posts expressed affection for the product and another 14% expressed an intent to buy.
The model’s successor, the Nokia 925, was then announced on May 14, 2013. We see that promotion for the Nokia 925 announcement and ultimate mid-June release sparked more conversation about the Nokia 920. Social media often serves as reminder advertising for companies in the wake of rebranding.
Dated models such as the Nokia 100 are the last thing Microsoft wants its latest acquisition to be remembered for. If we combine these results with sentiment offered online over the past week discussing the acquisition, we can see who the public thinks the acquisition is benefitting the most.
We see the clearest disparity in sentiment on the day of the acquisition. The breakdown over the week of the acquisition reveals that a greater percentage of conversation identifies Nokia as a poor acquisition by Microsoft than all of the positive topic percentages combined. In fact, only 2% of posts believe Nokia’s mobile business to be a strong acquisition.
On the other hand, 19% of positive conversation is excited by the rebrand with 9% pledging loyalty to their new service.
@nokia & @Microsoft are officially one company now, Congrats!
— Mushahid Hussain (@nothanks91) April 25, 2014
4% of conversation came in the form of advice for Microsoft. Many of these posts revealed a demand to keep the Nokia name in rotation, expressing sentiment that the Microsoft Mobile rebrand is too much, too soon.
@NMShenoy so if MS is smart, they keep Nokia on all of their phones for 2 years and first call them Nokia MIcrosoft phones, then switch…
— Tomi T Ahonen Stands With Ukraine (@tomiahonen) April 24, 2014
@nokia please Microsoft at least keep Nokia written on boxes and phones and other Nokia products.
— maninder (@gagmani) April 25, 2014
The public also reminded Microsoft that holding onto the manufacturer’s name has been done before:
Microsoft Mobile? Seriously? Please keep the Nokia brand name. Follow Google's example with Motorola and use the brand to innovate.
— Micheal Mullen (@idiottech) April 25, 2014
We know people are resistant to change and company transitions like these are a delicate process. Any connection the public has to the Nokia brand must be carefully assessed and addressed in Microsoft’s rebranding efforts. We see that talk of the acquisition is most prevalent in the India affinity, a place where Nokia products are both manufactured and used on a grand scale. Those talking about Indian news and other related topics are tweeting 49x more often about Microsoft Mobile than the average Twitter user.
Microsoft again recognised one more Indian origin…Microsoft who has acquired Nokia has appointed Indian born Rajeev Suri as its new CEO…
— Karthik (@sweetkar8788) April 29, 2014
Another notable affinity talking about the acquisition is Apple, and that’s never a bad thing. 18% of this analysis is tied to the Apple affinity, and Apple affinity members are discussing the Microsoft Mobile acquisition 8x more often than the average Tweeter. Interestingly, this acquisition makes more sense to those with a greater awareness of the industry and perhaps of Nokia’s true value.
Nokia’s split public identity, torn between a technology provider that has already seen its prime and a relevant, competitive Smartphone manufacturer, has limited the company’s growth and overall positioning in the market. Microsoft hopes their most-recent acquisition will rebrand the services and respark momentum within the mobile device industry. Nokia- you are in good hands.
Whether for better or for worse, Nokia is officially a part of the Microsoft family. Let us remember Nokia for its pioneering efforts in mobile phone technology, and long live Microsoft Mobile. As always, we can count on social media to offer perspective and raise the next big question:
Everone's talking about Microsoft after the sale of Nokia phones. I'm eager to learn what Nokia will do with the cash.
— Antti Vilpponen (@vilpponen) April 26, 2014
Comments on this article are closed.